全部 标题 作者
关键词 摘要

OALib Journal期刊
ISSN: 2333-9721
费用:99美元

查看量下载量

Wind Turbines: An Exploration of Research Participants’ Living Experiences as a Consequence of Ontario’s Green Energy Act

DOI: 10.4236/oalib.1110043, PP. 1-32

Subject Areas: Sociology, Civil Engineering

Keywords: Wind Turbines, Green Energy Act, Government Policy, Grounded Theory, Contemplating to Vacate a Home, Housing Decisions (Internationally, USA, Canada)

Full-Text   Cite this paper   Add to My Lib

Abstract

In 2009, the province of Ontario, Canada enacted the Green Energy Act. Those appealing an approval of a Wind Power Plant (WPP) were challenged by a high burden of proof—proof of causality. The requirement was that, before the project was constructed and operating, it must be shown that it “will cause” serious harm to human health, or “serious and irreversible harm” to plant or animal life, or the natural environment. Methods: This ethicsreviewed study used the Grounded Theory methodology. It conducted face-to-face interviews with those who had previously lived or were currently living within 10 km from a WPP. Audio files were transcribed to text, and the data were coded and analysed using NVivo Pro (v.12.6) software. Objectives: To explore and generate a substantive theory of the events that motivate research participants living within 10 km from a WPP to contemplate their housing decisions. Results: Data analysis revealed that the Green Energy Act contributed towards participants considering their housing decisions. They became informed and took action by participating in government processes that included observing Environmental Review Tribunals, other judicial proceedings and filing complaints/Incident Reports. Discussion: Through the candid and insightful observations by research participants, those with an interest in health policy, authorities, policy makers, researchers, practitioners, social scientists, and members of the public, will gain an awareness of the effects the Green Energy Act had on research participants.

Cite this paper

Krogh, C. M. , McMurtry, R. Y. , Johnson, W. B. , Punch, J. L. , Dumbrille, A. , Alves-Pereira, M. , Hughes, D. , Rogers, L. , Rand, R. W. , James, R. , Ambrose, S. E. and Gillis, L. (2023). Wind Turbines: An Exploration of Research Participants’ Living Experiences as a Consequence of Ontario’s Green Energy Act. Open Access Library Journal, 10, e043. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1110043.

References

[1]  Wind Energy Technologies Office (n.d.) How a Wind Turbine Works—Text Version. https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/how-wind-turbine-works-text-version
[2]  Green Energy and Green Economy Act, 2009, S.O. 2009, c. 12-Bill 150. https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/s09012
[3]  Dunn, C. (2010, June 10) Ontario’s Green Energy Act. Greener Ideal. https://greenerideal.com/news/politics/canada/7062-ontarios-green-energy-act
[4]  Bioenergy International (2018, December 11) Ontario Repeals the Green Energy Act. https://bioenergyinternational.com/ontario-repeals-the-green-energy-act/
[5]  Krogh, C.M., McMurtry, R.Y., Dumbrille, A., Hughes, D. and Gillis, L. (2018) Preliminary Results: Exploring Why Some Families Living in Proximity to Wind Turbine Facilities Contemplate Vacating Their Homes—A Community-Based Study. Open Access Library Journal, 7, 1-8. https://doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1106118
[6]  Krogh, C.M., McMurtry, R.Y., Johnson, B.W., et al. (2020) Wind Turbines: Why Some Families Living in Proximity to Wind Energy Facilities Contemplate Vacating Their Homes: An Overview of Findings. Open Access Library Journal, 7, e6443. https://doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1106443
[7]  Krogh, C.M., McMurtry, R.Y., Johnson, B.W., et al. (2021) Grounded Theory as an Analytical Tool to Explore Housing Decisions Related to Living in the Vicinity of Industrial Wind Turbines. Open Access Library Journal, 8, e7233. https://scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=108027https://www.scirp.org/pdf/oalibj_2021032516361728.pdf https://doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1107233
[8]  Spinks, N. (2014) Grounded Theory. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Grounded-Theory-Spinks/6182186784d792ed09c4129924a46f9e88869407?p2df
[9]  Castillo-Montoya, M. (2016) Preparing for Interview Research: The Interview Protocol Refinement Framework. The Qualitative Report, 21, 811-831. https://doi.org/10.46743/2160-3715/2016.2337
[10]  OMB (Ontario Municipal Board). Issue Date: July. 16, 2007. Decision/Order No: 1989. PL060986. J. P. Atcheson, Member. Testimony by d’Entremont D (a); Brownell R (b); Marshall E (c).
[11]  Fraser, H. (2008, November 13) Helen Fraser Interview: Melancthon I, Shelburne, Ontario. https://www.wind-watch.org/documents/helen-fraser-interview-melancthon-i-shelburne-ontario
[12]  Standing Committee on General Government. April 15, 2009. Green Energy and Green Economy Act, 2009. Legislative Assembly of Ontario. Hansard. Ashbee B (a. G-515 & G-518); MacLeod S (b. G-547); Ripley Group (c. G-547-G-549); Wylds G (d. G-549); Hutton P (e. G-504); Morris J (f. G-501).
[13]  Standing Committee on General Government. April 22, 2009. Green Energy and Green Economy Act, 2009. Legislative Assembly of Ontario. Hansard. McMurtry RY. pg G-664.
[14]  Krogh, C.M.E., Gillis, L., Kouwen, N. and Aramini, J. (2011) WindVOiCe, a Self-Reporting Survey: Adverse Health Effects, Industrial Wind Turbines, and the Need for Vigilance Monitoring. Bulletin of Science Technology & Society, 31, 334-345. https://doi.org/10.1177/0270467611412551
[15]  Whiteley, A. and Dumbrille, A. (2021) Ontario’s Green Energy Policy vs. Social Justice. Open Journal of Social Sciences, 9, 447-486. https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2021.91033
[16]  McKitrick, R.R. (2013) Environmental and Economic Consequences of Ontario’s Green Energy Act. Ontario Prosperity Initiative. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2317462
[17]  Fast, S., Mabee, W., Baxter, J., et al. (2016) Lessons Learned from Ontario Wind Energy Disputes. Perspective. Nature Energy, 1, Article No. 15028. https://doi.org/10.1038/nenergy.2015.28
[18]  Ferguson, R. (2009, February 11) McGuinty Vows to Stop Wind-Farm NIMBYs. https://www.thestar.com/news/ontario/2009/02/11/mcguinty_vows_to_stop_windfarm_nimbys.html
[19]  Richardson, T. (2013, February 20) Turbines Are Affecting People: Lynn. https://www.owensoundsuntimes.com/2013/02/20/turbines-are-affecting-people-lynn/wcm/a4bbabd0-99b7-6511-239a-13046064a0d2
[20]  BioInitiative Working Group, Sage, C. and Carpenter, D.O. (Eds.) (December 31, 2012) BioInitiative Report: A Rationale for Biologically-Based Public Exposure Standards for Electromagnetic Radiation. https://www.bioinitiative.org
[21]  Punch, J.L. and James, R.R. (2016) Wind Turbine Noise and Human Health: A Four-Decade History of Evidence that Wind Turbines Pose Risks. https://docs.wind-watch.org/Punch-James-Wind-Turbine-Noise-16-10-21.pdf
[22]  ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario). Decision: 10-121/10-122. Dated This 18th Day of July, 2011. Erickson v. Director. Ministry of the Environment. pg 190 & 207.
[23]  Beaudry, R. (2012, November 12) ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario): 12-148. MCSEA Inc. Definition Clarification. Personal Correspondence. Ontario Ministry of the Environment.
[24]  Meuleman, D. (2012, November 29) Subject: RE: ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario): 12-148. Definition Clarification. Crown Counsel. Ministry of the Attorney General. Legal Services Branch. Ministry of the Environment.
[25]  Environment and Land Tribunals Ontario. Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario. December 10, 2012. A Notice of Withdrawal and Cancellation of Preliminary Hearing and Hearing Case No.: 12-148. In the Matter of an Appeal by Manitoulin Coalition for Safe Energy Alternatives Inc. Symonds D. Deputy Registrar.
[26]  Rogers, L. (2016, April 22) Hedley K: Correspondence from the Ministry of Environment and Climate Change. Ministry of Environment and Climate Change, Ontario, Canada.
[27]  Ontario News Room (December 7, 2018) Ontario Scraps the Green Energy Act. Will Protect Consumers, Restore Municipal Authority over Energy Projects. Northern Development and Mines. https://news.ontario.ca/en/release/50684/ontario-scraps-the-green-energy-act
[28]  Wilson, J. (2022, September 9) Problematic Melancthon Wind Farm Contract Extended to 2031. https://citizen.on.ca/problematic-melancthon-wind-farm-contract-extended-to-2031/
[29]  Hill, S. and Knott, J. (2010) Too Close for Comfort: Social Controversies Surrounding Wind Farm Noise Setback Policies in Ontario. Renewable Energy Law and Policy Review, 1, 153-168. https://www.jstor.org/stable/24324603
[30]  Shain, M. (2011) Public Health Ethics, Legitimacy, and the Challenges of Industrial Wind Turbines: The Case of Ontario, Canada. Bulletin of Science Technology & Society, 31, 6. https://doi.org/10.1177/0270467611412552
[31]  McRobert, D., Tennent-Riddell, J. and Walker, C. (2016) Ontario’s Green Economy and Green Energy Act: Why a Well-Intentioned Law Is Mired in Controversy and Opposed by Rural Communities. Renewable Energy Law and Policy Review, 7, 91-112. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26256490?seq=1 https://doi.org/10.4337/relp.2016.02.01
[32]  Evans, A. (2017) Environmental Noise Pollution: Has Public Health Become Too Utilitarian? Open Journal of Social Sciences, 5, 80-107. https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2017.55007
[33]  Kraft, J.M. (2013, September 8) “Our Living Hell”—Life Next to Wind Turbines. https://edgarcountywatchdogs.com/2013/09/our-living-hell-life-next-to-wind-turbines/?fbclid=IwAR0_4SlVx8QBh_yhAErq0ChUlOptqB1356Qo-VRUZj1zqzk03S7u8tY8-a8#respond
[34]  Public Health Presentation (September 10, 2019) Health Impacts of Industrial Wind: Dan Stapelton WNY Health Alliance. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWwLAxIaiYY&feature=emb_logo
[35]  Wilson, J., Krogh, C. and Peel, P.C. (2020) Déja vu and Wind Turbines: A Review of Lived Experiences after Appeals of Ontario Industrial-Scale Wind Power Facilities. Open Access Library Journal, 7, e6276. https://doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1106276
[36]  ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario). Case Nos.: 10-121/10-122. In the Matter of Appeals by Katie Brenda Erickson and Chatham-Kent Wind Action Inc. Filed on November 29, 2010 for a Hearing before the Environmental Review Tribunal Pursuant to Section 142.1 of the Environmental Protection Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.19, as Amended with Respect to a Renewable Energy Approval Issued by the Director, Ministry of the Environment, on November 10, 2010 to Kent Breeze Corp. and MacLeod Windmill Project Inc. (Kent Breeze Wind Farms) c/o Suncor Energy Services Inc. under Section 47.5 of the Environmental Protection Act, Regarding the Construction, Installation, Operation, Use and Retiring of Eight Wind Turbine Generators Located at Part Lots 8-11, Concession 1 and Part Lots 4-6, Concession 1 & 2, in the Township of Camden, Municipality of Chatham-Kent, Ontario. (Witness a. pg 64); (Winess b. pg 90).
[37]  ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario). Case No. 14-096. Decision. Niagara Region Wind Corporation. May 20, 2015. Mothers against Wind Turbines Inc, Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change, and Niagara Region Wind Corporation. Subject of Appeal: Renewable Energy Approval for Niagara Region Company Reference No.: 4353-9HMP2R. Summary of testimony by Jankowski MA (a. pg.19). Atkins S (b, pg.16). Correia S (c). PDF copies of the ERT’s Decision and Correia’s Transcript and Letter from the Physician Specialist Available on Request.
[38]  ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario). 2016. Case Nos. 13-002/13-003. Alliance to Protect Prince Edward County and Prince Edward County Field Naturalists vs Ministry of Environment (“Director”) and Ostrander Point GP Inc. General Partner for/and Behalf of Ostrander Point Wind Energy LP. Testimony under oath by Elmes E. May 9, 2016 (a); Davey M. May 14, 2013 (b) Michaud L. May 15, 2016 (c&d); Johnson S and Desmond D, May 21, 2016 (d&e); Kenny E. May 22, 2013 (f); Whitworth T. May 23, 2015 (g); Horton N and White J. May 24, 2016 (h&i); Johnson S. May 21, 2013 and May 22, 2013 (j&k).
[39]  ERT. (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario). September 24, 2013. Case Nos. 13-084/13-085/13-086/13-087/13-088/13-89. Dixon, S. and Ryan, T. and C.; Middlesex-Lambton Wind Action Group Inc. and Wrightman, H. vs St. Columban Energy Inc as General Partner for and on Behalf of St. Columban Energy L.P. Testimony under Oath by Ashbee B (a) & MacLeod S (b).
[40]  ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario). Case Nos.: 13-002/13-003. Decision, July 3, 2013. Alliance to Protect Prince Edward County v. Director, Ministry of the Environment. In the Matter of Appeals by Alliance to Protect Prince Edward County and Prince Edward County Field Naturalists. Robert V. Wright, Panel Chair and Heather I. Gibbs, Vice-Chair. Para: 57,628,630,645.
[41]  ERT (Environmental Review Tribunal of Ontario). Issue Date: August 16, 2017. Case No.: 16-036. Decision Delivered By Dirk Vanderbent and Hugh S. Wilkins. Proceeding Commenced under Section 142.1(2) of the Environmental Protection Act, R.S.O. 1990, c.E.19, as Amended.
[42]  Palmer, W.K.G. (2011, January 4) Review of Enbridge Ontario Wind Power Compliance with Ministry of Environment Certificate of Approval (Air) Noise. Submitted to Chappell, District Manager, Owen Sound District Office. Copy: Dr. Hazel Lynn. Medical Officer of Health. Owen Sound, Ontario and Mr. M Smith, Warden. County of Bruce. Walkerton, Ontario.
[43]  WCO (Wind Concerns Ontario). April 2021. Response to Wind Turbine Noise Complaints. By Ontario’s Environment Ministry. Fourth Report 2018. https://www.windconcernsontario.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Report-on-Noise-Complaint-Response-2018-FINAL.pdf
[44]  Ministry of Environment. West Central Region. September 30, 2009. Log: ENV1283MC-2009_4345. McLean C Personal Correspondence.
[45]  Devlin, C. (2017) Freedom from Unwarranted Experimentation. Open Journal of Social Sciences, 5, 23-48. https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2017.55003
[46]  250 Million Accusure Insulin Syringes Recalled. By ABC7. Wednesday, October 28, 2009. abc7news. https://abc7news.com/archive/7086777/
[47]  Health Canada (2010) Useful Information for Environmental Assessments. Authority of the Minister of Health, 8. https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2015/sc-hc/H128-1-10-599-eng.pdf
[48]  Honourable Rona Ambrose, P.C., M.P. June 30, 2009. Former Minister of Environment (Canada). Krogh C Personal Correspondence.
[49]  German Professors Initiative Group (September 1, 1998) Darmstadt Manifesto. https://www.wind-watch.org/documents/darmstadt-manifesto/
[50]  Wind Technology Road Map. https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/sites/www.nrcan.gc.ca/files/canmetenergy/pdf/fichier/81768/windtrm_summary_e.pdf
[51]  (2012) Health Canada’s Policy and Research Approach to Wind Turbines. Proceedings of Science Advisory Board Meeting, Ottawa, Ontario, 1-2 February 2012. https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/science-research/reports-publications/science-advice-decision-making/science-advisory-board-meeting-february-1-2-2012.html
[52]  (2015) Chapter 2: The Need for More Evidence-Based Health Advice on the Impact of Wind Turbines on Human Health. Introduction and Context. In: Select Committee on Wind Turbines, The Senate, Canberra, Canada. https://stopthesethings.files.wordpress.com/2015/08/senate-report.pdf
[53]  (January 18, 2012) The Brown County Board of Health Resolution Requesting Emergency State Aid for Families Suffering Around Industrial Wind Turbines. National Wind Watch, Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA. https://docs.wind-watch.org/Brown%20County%20Board%20of%20Health%20Resolution%20011012.pdf
[54]  The Brown County Citizens for Responsible Wind Energy (October 16, 2014) Duke Energy’s Shirley Wind Turbines Declared a “Human Health Hazard”. National Wind Watch, Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA. https://www.wind-watch.org/news/2014/10/16/duke-energys-shirley-wind-turbines-declared-a-human-health-hazard/
[55]  Falmouth (Mass.) Board of Health (2012) Request for Health Assessment. National Wind Watch, Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA. https://www.wind-watch.org/documents/request-for-health-assessment/
[56]  Belmont, S. (2019, August 12) Public Health Officials: Wind Turbines Bad for Your Health. https://www.wind-watch.org/news/2019/08/13/public-health-officials-wind-turbines-bad-for-your-health/
[57]  WHO (World Health Organization) (2008) Closing the Gap in a Generation: Health Equity through Action on the Social Determinants of Health. Final Report of the Commission on Social Determinants of Health. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-IER-CSDH-08.1
[58]  Health and Welfare Canada (1986) Achieving Health for All. A Framework for Health Promotion. https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/health-care-system/reports-publications/health-care-system/achieving-health-framework-health-promotion.html
[59]  INCE Europe: 8th International Conference on Wind Turbine Noise. Lisbon—12th to 14th June 2019. https://www.windturbinenoise.eu/files/post-conference-report-27jun.pdf
[60]  Dumbrille, A., McMurtry, R.Y. and Krogh, C.M. (2021) Wind Turbines and Adverse Health Effects: Applying Bradford Hill’s Criteria for Causation. Environmental Disease, 6, 65-87.
[61]  WHO (1999) Guidelines for Community Noise. Part 5. Noise Management. http://www.who.int/docstore/peh/noise/Comnoise-5.pdf
[62]  Goldstein, B.D. (2001) The Precautionary Principle Also Applies to Public Health Actions. American Journal of Public Health, 91, 1358-1361. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.91.9.1358

Full-Text


comments powered by Disqus

Contact Us

service@oalib.com

QQ:3279437679

WhatsApp +8615387084133

WeChat 1538708413