|
EPISTEME 2009
When Externalism And Privileged Self-Knowledge Are Compatible And When They Are NotKeywords: incompatibilism, slow-switching cases, reductio of compatibilism. Abstract: this paper is dedicated to the incompatibilist debate between externalism and privileged self-knowledge, such as it appears in the literature under two privileged contexts of discussion: the slow-switching cases and the reductio ad absurdum arguments. my aim is to defend a compatibilist position although recognising some exceptions to it. i will defend, on the one hand, that the incompatibilism reached by slow-switching cases is sustained only in case we maintain a specific but problematical view about self-knowledge. on the other hand, the incompatibilism reached by reductio ad absurdum arguments is only sustained if we maintain a narrow conception of externalism.
|