This paper presents a discussion of the literature on animal-assisted interventions and describes limitations surrounding current methodological quality. Benefits to human physical, psychological and social health cannot be empirically confirmed due to the methodological limitations of the existing body of research, and comparisons cannot validly be made across different studies. Without a solid research base animal-assisted interventions will not receive recognition and acceptance as a credible alternative health care treatment. The paper draws on the work of four systematic reviews conducted over April–May 2009, with no date restrictions, focusing exclusively on the use of canine-assisted interventions for older people residing in long-term care. The reviews revealed a lack of good quality studies. Although the literature base has grown in volume since its inception, it predominantly consists of anecdotal accounts and reports. Experimental studies undertaken are often flawed in aspects of design, conduct and reporting. There are few qualitative studies available leading to the inability to draw definitive conclusions. It is clear that due to the complexities associated with these interventions not all weaknesses can be eliminated. However, there are basic methodological weaknesses that can be addressed in future studies in the area. Checklists for quantitative and qualitative research designs to guide future research are offered to help address methodological rigour.
References
[1]
Chur-Hansen, A.; Stern, C.; Winefield, H. Gaps in the evidence about companion animals and human health: Some suggestions for progress. Int. J. Evid. Base Healthc. 2010, 8, 140–146, doi:10.1111/j.1744-1609.2010.00176.x.
[2]
Johnson, R.A.; Odendaal, J.S.J.; Meadows, R.L. Animal-assisted interventions research: Issues and answers. West. J. Nurs. Res. 2002, 24, 422–440, doi:10.1177/01945902024004009.
[3]
Wells, D.L. Domestic dogs and human health: An overview. Br. J. Health Psych. 2007, 12, 145–156, doi:10.1348/135910706X103284.
[4]
Wells, D.L. The effects of animals on human health and well-being. J. Soc. Issues 2009, 65, 523–543, doi:10.1111/j.1540-4560.2009.01612.x.
Stern, C. The appropriateness of Canine-Assisted Intervention (CAIs) on the health and social care of older people residing in long term care. JBI Library Syst. Rev. 2011, 9, 1367–1392.
[7]
Stern, C. The economic feasibility of Canine-Assisted Intervention (CAIs) on the health and social care of older people residing in long term care: A systematic review. JBI Library Syst. Rev. 2011, 9, 1341–1366.
[8]
Stern, C. The meaningfulness of Canine-Assisted Intervention (CAIs) on the health and social care of older people residing in long term care: A systematic review. JBI Library Syst. Rev. 2011, 9, 727–790.
[9]
Stern, C.; Konno, R. The effects of Canine-Assisted Interventions (CAIs) on the health and social care of older people residing in long term care: A systematic review. JBI Library Syst. Rev. 2011, 9, 146–206.
[10]
Phelps, K.A.; Miltenberger, R.G.; Jens, T.; Wadeson, H. An investigation of the effects of dog visits on depression, mood, and social interaction in elderly individuals living in a nursing home. Behav. Intervent. 2008, 23, 181–200, doi:10.1002/bin.263.
[11]
Fine, A. Handbook on Animal-Assisted Therapy: Theoretical Foundations and Guidelines for Practice, 2nd ed.; Elsevier: San Diego, CA, USA, 2006.
[12]
Definitions Development Task Force of the Standards Committee. Generic Terms and Definitions. Handbook for Animal Assisted Activities and Animal Assisted Therapy. Available online: http://www.avma.org/issues/policy/animal_assisted_guidelines.asp (accessed on 17 December 2012).
[13]
Delta Society. Animal-Assisted Activities/Therapy 101. Available online: http://www.deltasociety.org/Page.aspx?pid=317 (accessed on 17 December 2012).
[14]
DeMello, M. Animals and Society. An Introduction to Human-Animal Studies; Columbia University Press: New York, NY, USA, 2012.
[15]
Blazina, C.; Boyraz, G.; Shen-Miller, D. The Psychology of the Human-Animal Bond. A Resource for Clinicians and Researchers; Springer: New York, NY, USA, 2011.
[16]
Culliton, B.J. Take two pets and call me in the morning. Science 1987, 237, 1560–1561.
[17]
Beck, A.; Katcher, A. A new look at pet-facilitated therapy. J. Am. Med. Vet. Assoc. 1984, 184, 414–421.
[18]
Koivusilta, L.K.; Ojanlatva, A. To have or not to have a pet for better health? PLoS ONE 2006, 1, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0000109.
[19]
Furber, S. Effects of companion animals on the quality of life of older people: A critical review and research agenda. In Proceedings of Animals, Community Health and Public Policy Symposium, Sydney, Australia, 27 November 1998.
[20]
Filan, S.L.; Lewellyn-Jones, R.H.L. Animal-assisted therapy for dementia: A review of the literature. Int. Psychogeriatr. 2006, 18, 597–611, doi:10.1017/S1041610206003322.
[21]
Lutwack-Bloom, P.; Wijewickrama, R.; Smith, B. Effects of pets versus people visits with nursing home residents. JGSW 2005, 44, 137–159.
[22]
Banks, M.R.; Banks, W.A. The effects of animal-assisted therapy on loneliness in an elderly population in long-term care facilities. J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci. 2002, 57, M428–M423, doi:10.1093/gerona/57.7.M428.
[23]
Banks, M.R.; Banks, W.A. The effects of group and individual animal-assisted therapy on loneliness in residents of long-term care facilities. Anthrozo？s 2005, 18, 396–408, doi:10.2752/089279305785593983.
[24]
Banks, M.R.; Willoughby, L.M.; Banks, W.A. Animal-assisted therapy and loneliness in nursing homes: Use of robotic versus living dogs. J. Am. Med. Dir. Assoc. 2008, 9, 173–177, doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2007.11.007.
[25]
Wall, M.J. The Effects of Companion Animal Visitation on Mood State and Level of Speech Activity of Nursing Home Residents; California School of Professional Psychology: San Diego, CA, USA, 1994.
[26]
Zulauf, J.B. The Effectiveness of a Pet Therapy Visitation Program on the Institutionalized Elderly. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Montana, Missoula, MT, USA, 1987.
[27]
Reed, M.E. The Mascot Model of Human/Companion Animal Interaction: Its Effects on Levels of Loneliness and Depression Among Residents of a Nursing Home (Pet Theory); Western Conservative Baptist Seminary: Portland, OR, USA, 1986.
[28]
Marx, M.S.; Cohen-Mansfield, J.; Regier, N.G.; Dakheel-Ali, M.; Srihari, A.; Thein, K. The impact of different dog-related stimuli on engagement of persons with dementia. Am. J. Alzheimers. Dis. Other. Demen. 2010, 25, 37–45, doi:10.1177/1533317508326976.
[29]
Kongable, L.G.; Buckwalter, K.C.; Stolley, J.M. The effects of pet therapy on the social behaviour of institutionalized Alzheimer’s clients. Arch. Psychiatr. Nurs. 1989, 3, 191–198.
[30]
Harris, M.D.; Rinehart, J.M.; Gerstman, J. Animal-assisted therapy for the homebound elderly. Holist. Nurs. Pract. 1993, 8, 27–37.
[31]
McCabe, B.W.; Baun, M.M.; Speich, D.; Agrawal, S. Resident dog in the Alzheimer’s special care unit. West. J. Nurs. Res. 2002, 24, 684–696, doi:10.1177/019394502320555421.
[32]
Sellers, D.M. The evaluation of an animal assisted therapy intervention for elders with dementia in long-term care. Activ. Adapt. Aging 2005, 30, 61–77, doi:10.1300/J016v30n01_04.
[33]
Bohlinger, E.F. The Effects of the Frequency of Pet Therapy Sessions on the Depressive Symptoms of Elderly Nursing Home Residents. M.S. Thesis, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH, USA, 1985.
[34]
Hall, P.I.; Malpus, Z. Pets as therapy: Effects on social interaction in long-stay psychiatry. Br. J. Nurs. 2000, 9, 2220–2225.
[35]
Wallace, J.E.; Nadermann, S. Effects of pet visitations on semiambulatory nursing home residents: problems in assessment. J. Appl. Gerontol. 1987, 6, 183–188, doi:10.1177/073346488700600204.
[36]
Kramer, S.C.; Friedmann, E.; Bernstein, P.L. Comparison of the effect of human interaction, animal-assisted therapy, and AIBO-assisted therapy on long-term care residents with dementia. Anthrozo？s 2009, 22, 43–57.
[37]
Prosser, L.; Townsend, M.; Staiger, P. Older people’s relationships with companion animals: A pilot study. Nurs. Old. People 2008, 20, 29–32.
[38]
Walsh, P.G.; Mertin, P.G.; Verlander, D.F.; Pollard, C.F. The effects of a “pets as therapy” dog on persons with dementia in a psychiatric ward. Aust. Occup. Ther. J. 1995, 42, 161–166.
[39]
Motomura, N.; Yagi, T.; Ohyama, H. Animal assisted therapy for people with dementia. Psychogeriatrics 2004, 4, 40–42, doi:10.1111/j.1479-8301.2004.00062.x.
[40]
Bumsted, D.L. The Effect of Pet Therapy on the Self-Care of the Elderly. M.S. Thesis, Southern Connecticut State University, New Haven, CT, USA, 1988.
[41]
Panzer-Koplow, S.L. Effects of Animal-Assisted Therapy on Depression and Morale Among Nursing Home Residents. Ed.D. Thesis, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, NJ, USA, 2000.
[42]
Richeson, N.E. Effects of animal-assisted therapy on agitated behaviours and social interactions of older adults with dementia. Am. J. Alzheimers. Dis. Other. Demen. 2003, 18, 353–358, doi:10.1177/153331750301800610.
[43]
Kaiser, L.; Spence, L.J.; McGavin, L.; Struble, L.; Keilman, L. A dog and a “Happy Person” visit nursing home residents. West. J. Nurs. Res. 2002, 24, 422–440, doi:10.1177/01945902024004009.
[44]
Whaley, M.E. Staff Perceptions of the Effects of Animal Facilitated Therapy on Institutionalized Elderly. M.S. Thesis, California State University, Long Beach, CA, USA, 1996.
[45]
Andrysco, R.M. A Study of Ethologic and Therapeutic Factors of Pet-Facilitated Therapy in a Retirement-Nursing Community. Ph.D. Thesis, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA, 1982.
[46]
Perkins, J.; Bartlett, H.; Travers, C.; Rand, J. Dog-assisted therapy for older people with dementia: A review. Australas. J. Ageing 2008, 27, 177–182, doi:10.1111/j.1741-6612.2008.00317.x.
[47]
Winkler, A.; Fairnie, H.; Gericevich, F.; Long, M. The impact of a resident dog on an institution for the elderly: Effects on perceptions and social interactions. The Gerontologist 1989, 29, 216–223, doi:10.1093/geront/29.2.216.
[48]
Barak, Y.; Savorai, O.; Mavashev, S; Beni, A. Animal-assisted therapy for elderly schizophrenic patients. A one-year controlled trial. Am. J. Geriatr. Psychiatry 2001, 9, 439–442.
[49]
Crowley-Robinson, P.; Fenwick, D.C.; Blackshaw, J.K. A long-term study of elderly people in nursing homes with visiting and resident dogs. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 1996, 47, 137–148, doi:10.1016/0168-1591(95)01017-3.
[50]
Williams, E.; Jenkins, R. Dog visitation therapy in dementia care: A literature review. Nurs. Old. People 2008, 20, 31–35.
[51]
Pope, C.; Mays, N. Qualitative Research in Health Care, 3rd ed.; Blackwell Publishing Ltd.: Oxford, UK, 2007.
[52]
Joanna Briggs Institute Reviewers’ Manual. The Joanna Briggs Institute, 2008. Available online: www.joannabriggs.edu.au/.../JBIReviewManual_CiP11449.pdf (accessed on 17 December 2012).
[53]
Graneheim, U.H.; Lundman, B. Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: Concepts, procedures and measures to achieve trustworthiness. Nurs. Educ. Today 2004, 24, 105–112, doi:10.1016/j.nedt.2003.10.001.
[54]
Savishinsky, J. Pets and family relationships among nursing home residents. Marriage Fam. Rev. 1985, 8, 109–134, doi:10.1300/J002v08n03_09.
[55]
Kongable, L.G.; Stolley, J.M.; Buckwalter, K. Pet therapy for Alzheimer’s patients: A survey. J. Long Term Care Adm. 1990, 18, 17–21.
[56]
Cirulli, F.; Borgi, M.; Berry, A.; Francia, N.; Alleva, E. Animal-assisted interventions as innovative tools for mental health. Ann. Ist. Super Sanita. 2011, 47, 341–348.
[57]
Consort. Available online: www.consort-statement.org/consort-statement/ (accessed on 2 February 2013).
