|
浅析律师保密义务与公共利益的冲突及解决途径
|
Abstract:
律师的保密义务作为律师职业道德中最为重要的一项职业伦理,是委托人与律师建立信任关系的基础。律师在执业的时候应当恪守保护委托人的秘密这一原则进行委托行为,然而在律师执业过程中,基于其职业特性将不可避免地面临职业伦理与大众道德认知的冲突。本文以律师的保密义务为切入点探求法律职业伦理所具有的独特性质以及当律师的保密义务与公共利益发生冲突的时候,律师应当严格遵守保密义务以及法律规定的例外情形,严格把握律师的保密义务与保护公共利益之间的平衡点。可在我国设立律师拒绝作证制度,完善律师保密权相关立法,最终促进公平正义在每一个案件之中的实现。
As one of the most important professional ethics in the professional ethics of lawyers, the confidentiality obligation of lawyers is the foundation of the trust relationship between clients and lawyers. Lawyers should abide by the principle of protecting clients’ secrets when practicing. However, in the process of practicing lawyers, based on their professional characteristics, they will inevitably face the conflict between professional ethics and public moral cognition. This paper explores the unique nature of legal professional ethics with lawyers’ confidentiality obligation as the starting point, and when lawyers’ confidentiality obligation conflicts with public interests, lawyers should strictly adhere to their confidentiality obligations while also observing the exceptional cases stipulated by law. The article argues for maintaining a delicate balance between lawyers’ confidentiality obligations and the protection of public interests. It suggests establishing a system in China that allows lawyers to refuse to testify, improving legislation related to lawyers’ confidentiality rights, and ultimately promoting fairness and justice in every case.
[1] | 司莉. 律师保密义务有关理论问题探讨[J]. 河南财经政法大学学报, 2015, 30(2): 107-115. |
[2] | 皮剑龙. 论律师在执业中的保密特权[J]. 中国司法, 2009(4): 62-64. |
[3] | 邹淑环. 中国律师应如何应对“快乐湖尸案” [J]. 法制与经济(下旬), 2011(5): 63-64. |
[4] | 杨仕民, 王乾坤. 从快乐湖沉尸案看律师的保密义务[J]. 法制博览(中旬刊), 2013(2): 14-16. |
[5] | 李学尧. 非道德性: 现代法律职业伦理的困境[J]. 中国法学, 2010(1): 26-38. |
[6] | 姜保忠. 作证抑或保密:律师执业中的两难选择[J]. 法治研究, 2014(1): 126-131. |
[7] | 陆越. 律师保密义务的道德困境及解决途径[D]: [硕士学位论文]. 太原: 山西大学, 2013. |
[8] | 黄文, 蒲菊花. 律师的拒绝作证权探索[J]. 重庆教育学院学报, 2003(4): 5-8+111. |
[9] | 曹振. 我国律师保密权制度的不足及其完善[J]. 湖北警官学院学报, 2013, 26(11): 125-128. |
[10] | 李倩. 律师职业伦理的困境——以保密义务为视角[J]. 法制与社会, 2021(12): 144-145. |
[11] | 张旭昌. 律师保密义务的道德困境[J]. 法制与社会, 2008(23): 329-330. |