|
Dispute Settlement 2024
我国冷冻胚胎的法律属性界定及处置权规范构建
|
Abstract:
冷冻胚胎属于人类辅助生殖技术的范畴,对其定性和处置牵涉到医学、伦理、法律等领域的诸多问题,具有相当的复杂性,为解决冷冻胚胎纠纷无法得到合理解决、司法裁判不一的问题,首先要求明确冷冻胚胎的性质。其次,冷冻胚胎处置的纠纷主要集中在胚胎的移植和返还,本文通过对美国法三种处置模式进行分析,尝试以“原则 规则”的形式构建冷冻胚胎处置纠纷的解决框架,为司法实践提供进路。
Frozen embryos belong to the category of human assisted reproductive technology. Their characterization and disposal involve many issues in the fields of medicine, ethics, law, etc., which are quite complex. In order to solve the problem of frozen embryo disputes that cannot be reasonably resolved and judicial decisions are inconsistent, first of all, it is required to clarify the nature of frozen embryos. Secondly, disputes over the disposal of frozen embryos mainly focus on the transplantation and return of embryos. This article analyzes the three disposal models in U.S. law and attempts to construct a resolution framework for disputes over the disposal of frozen embryos in the form of “principles rules” to provide guidance for judicial practice road.
[1] | 北大法宝. 全国首例已故夫妻冷冻胚胎权属纠纷案审结[EB/OL]. http://www.pkulaw.cn/fulltext_form.aspx?Db=news&Gid=424fb035cd4f1772bdfb&isFromV6=1, 2014-09-18. |
[2] | 张善斌, 李雅男. 人类胚胎的法律地位及胚胎立法的制度构建[J]. 科技与法律, 2014(2): 276-295. |
[3] | Sheinbach, D.M. (1999) Examining Disputes over Ownership Rights to Frozen Embryos: Will Prior Consent Documents Survive If Challenged by State and/or Constitutional Principles? Catholic University Law Review, 48, 989-1001. |
[4] | 杨立新. 人的冷冻胚胎的法律属性及其继承问题[J]. 人民司法, 2014(13): 25-30. |
[5] | 冷传莉. 论民法中的人格物[M]. 北京: 法律出版社, 2011: 39. |
[6] | 杨永华. 人类冷冻胚胎的法律属性及处置问题研究[J]. 云南民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2018, 35(2): 149-153. |
[7] | 刘颖, 杨健. 胚胎的法律属性及其处置规则刍议[J]. 中国卫生法制, 2014, 22(1): 4-725. |
[8] | 贾爱玲. “冷冻胚胎”的法律属性及其处置规则[J]. 兰州学刊, 2017(11): 128-137. |
[9] | 李燕. 冷冻胚胎的权利归属及权利行使规则研究[J]. 人民司法, 2014(13): 35-40. |
[10] | 赵国平, 蒋继贫. 论冷冻胚胎之处置权[J]. 武汉理工大学学报(社会科学版), 2020, 33(4): 133-137. |
[11] | Coleman, C.H. (1999) Procreative Liberty and Contemporaneous Choice: An Inalienable Rights Approach to Frozen Embryo Disputes. Minnesota Law Review, 84, 55-127. |
[12] | 李昊. 冷冻胚胎的法律性质及其处置模式——以美国法为中心[J]. 华东政法大学学报, 2015, 18(5): 57-69. |
[13] | Howell, S.D. (2013) The Frozen Embryo: Scholarly Theories, Case Law, and Proposed State Regulation. DePaul Journal of Health Care Law, 14, 407-416. |
[14] | 杨立新. 一份标志人伦与情理胜诉的民事判决——人的体外胚胎权属争议案二审判决释评[J]. 法律适用, 2014(11): 48-55. |
[15] | 周佳慧. 冷冻胚胎的法律属性与私法处置规则研究[D]: [硕士学位论文]. 大连: 辽宁师范大学, 2023. |
[16] | 徐凤. 冷冻胚胎处置纠纷案的裁判路径[J]. 法律适用, 2023(11): 157-165. |
[17] | 杨恩乾. 论人体冷冻胚胎相关案件的裁判路径[J]. 法律适用, 2022(9): 13-20. |