环境权入宪的宪法反思
Constitutional Reflections on the Constitutionalisation of Environmental Rights

生态文明入宪具有重大的时代意义，环境权入宪与否问题再一次引起关注，此时，应当对环境权入宪的必要性问题进行冷静的思考。首先，环境权的权利性质和权利主体并不明确；其次，环境权与现有的宪法基本权利体系存在冲突且其可诉性也存在争议；再次，环境权入宪可能会对宪法带来不利影响，造成宪法权利的泛化，削弱宪法的权威；最后，环境权入宪并非实现环境治理的最佳方式，以宪法为统领，通过对各部门法的进一步细化构建“国家目标”型的环境治理模式，才能更好地发挥效用。
The inclusion of ecological civilisation in the constitution is of great significance in this era, and the question of whether environmental rights should be included in the constitution has once again attracted attention, and at this time, the necessity of the inclusion of environmental rights in the constitution should be considered in a calm manner. Firstly, the nature of the right and the subject of the right of environmental rights are not clear; secondly, the environmental rights are in conflict with the existing constitutional fundamental rights system and their justiciability is also controversial; thirdly, the constitutionalisation of the environmental rights may adversely affect the constitution, resulting in the generalisation of the constitutional rights and weakening of the authority of the constitution; finally, the constitutionalisation of environmental rights is not the best way to achieve environmental governance; a \"national goal\" model of environmental governance, led by the Constitution and further refined by sectoral laws, would be more effective.