|
赎刑制度的特点评议与当代价值
|
Abstract:
赎刑制度是以财物、劳役或身份折抵刑罚的一种刑罚替代方法。发端于夏朝,废止于清代,具有维护国家稳定、保护特权阶层、满足财政经济、体现仁政态度的诸多特点。虽然诞生于封建专制背景下的赎刑制度有着天然的阶级弊端,但制度本身对现代法律而言极具参照价值,有利于从刑事实体法上建立被害人弥补机制、缓和自由刑的存废争议、弥补司法经费不足。重构赎刑制度,与轻罪轻刑化的发展趋势具有同一性,体现了我国对法律本土资源酌水知源、去糟取精的传承态度,为中国特色法治建设开辟新道路。
The redemption system is an alternative method of punishment by exchanging property, labor or status for punishment. It was developed in the Xia Dynasty and abolished in the Qing Dynasty, and had many characteristics of maintaining the stability of the state, protecting the privileged class, satisfying the financial economy, and reflecting the benevolent attitude of government. Although the redemption system was born in the background of feudal autocracy, it has natural class disadvantages, but the system itself has reference value for modern law, which is conducive to establishing a victim compensation mechanism in substantive criminal law, easing the controversy over the retention or abolition of free sentences, and making up for the lack of judicial funding. The reconstruction of the redemption system is the same as the development trend of lightening the penalty for minor crimes, which reflects our country’s inheritance attitude of knowing the source of the local legal resources and removing the bad ones, and opens up a new path for the construction of the rule of law with Chinese characteristics.
[1] | 余邵鱼. 东周列国志[M]. 北京: 人民美术出版社, 2007. |
[2] | 沈家本. 汉律遮遗中册[M]. 北京: 商务印书馆股份有限公司, 1976. |
[3] | 南玉泉. 读秦汉简牍再论赎刑[J]. 中国古代法律文献研究, 2012(1): 17. |
[4] | 张健, 张佳, 李滨. 唐代赎刑制度考评议[J]. 湘潭师范学院学报(社会科学版), 2006, 28(4): 14-16. |
[5] | 马端临. 文献通考. 下册[M]. 北京: 中华书局, 1986. |
[6] | 杜伟伟. 宋代赎刑研究——以刑罚功能为视角[J]. 商丘师范学院学报, 2020, 36(2): 77-81. |
[7] | 怀效锋. 大明律(附大明令, 问刑案例) [M]. 沈阳: 辽沈书社, 1990. |
[8] | 陈金全. 中国传统司法与司法传统[M]. 西安: 陕西师范大学出版社, 2009. |
[9] | 马建石, 杨育棠. 大清律例通考校注[M]. 北京: 中国政法大学出版社, 1992. |
[10] | 祝庆祺. 刑案汇览三编[M]. 北京: 北京古籍出版社, 2004. |
[11] | 熊谋林, 刘任. 大清帝国的赎刑: 基于《刑案汇览》的实证研究[J]. 法学, 2019(6): 100-121. |
[12] | 刘俊文. 唐律疏议笺解[M]. 北京: 中华书局, 1996. |
[13] | 钱大群. 唐律疏义新注[M]. 南京: 南京师范大学出版社, 2007. |
[14] | 浙江省杭州市西湖区人民法院(2009)杭西刑初字第337号刑事判决书[Z]. |
[15] | 孙剑明, 张建刚, 钱丽娜. 短刑犯减刑联合考察与检察监督[J]. 法学, 2010(6): 154-160. |
[16] | 赵秉志, 陈志军. 短期自由刑改革方式比较研究[J]. 政法论坛, 2003(5): 87-99. |
[17] | 尚洪立, 李文铎, 厚德顺, 李进生, 冯世联. 科学规范缓刑适用正确发挥刑罚功能——山东省德州中院关于缓刑适用情况的调研报告[N]. 人民法院报, 2015-04-16(001). |
[18] | 陈永生. 域外司法经费: 管理相似保障充足[N]. 检察日报, 2015-03-03(001). |
[19] | 国库司. 2021年财政收支情况[Z/OL].
http://gks.mof.gov.cn/tongjishuju/202201/t20220128_3785692.htm, 2022-01-29. |