|
Dispute Settlement 2023
合规负责人的不作为参与
|
Abstract:
合规负责人是指在企业中从事风险识别、合规审查工作的主体。合规负责人在企业治理中,负有风险识别义务、合规审查义务,保证企业的正常运行。以实质义务论为视角进行考察,合规负责人具有信息优势,因此处于支配地位,当先行行为导致风险升高时,负有监督保证人义务。通过垂直授权没有决策权的合规负责人,仅对于风险的发生具有报告义务,不具有阻止法益侵害发生的义务。合规负责人不作为的刑事责任不宜过分扩张,除义务来源外还应当结合作为可能性进行考察。通过判断合规负责人是否具有成立不作为共犯的实行行为性,得出合规负责人不作为参与原则上应认定为帮助犯。
Compliance officer refers to the entity engaged in risk identification and compliance review work in an enterprise. Compliance officers are responsible for risk identification and compliance review in corporate governance to ensure the normal operation of the enterprise. From the perspective of substantive obligation theory, compliance officers have an information advantage and are therefore in a dominant position. When the prior behavior leads to increased risk, they have the obligation to supervise the guarantor. Compliance officers who do not have decisionmaking power through vertical authorization have a reporting obligation only for the occurrence of risks and do not have an obligation to prevent legal infringement. The criminal responsibility of compliance officers for inaction should not be excessively expanded, and in addition to the source of obligations, the possibility of inaction should also be examined. By determining whether the compliance officer has the ability to establish an accomplice in non action, it is concluded that in principle, the compliance officer’s participation in non action should be recognized as an accomplice.
[1] | 蔡仙. 论企业合规的刑法激励制度[J]. 法律科学(西北政法大学学报), 2021, 39(5): 154-170. |
[2] | 李本灿. 合规官的保证人义务来源及其履行[J]. 法学, 2020(6): 76-94. |
[3] | 张小宁. 论合规负责人的保证人义务——以证券犯罪为示例[J]. 东方法学, 2021(5): 135-149. |
[4] | 高铭暄, 马克昌. 刑法学[M]. 第八版. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2017: 68. |
[5] | 张明楷. 刑法学[M]. 第六版. 北京: 法律出版社, 2021: 198. |
[6] | 张明楷. 外国刑法纲要[M]. 第三版. 北京: 法律出版社, 2020: 82-83. |
[7] | 李本灿. 公共机构腐败治理合规路径的构建——以《刑法》第397条的解释为中心[J]. 中国刑事法杂志, 2019(2): 25-46. |
[8] | 王志祥, 融昊. 刑事合规中主体监管义务的教义学分析[J]. 法律适用, 2021(7): 51-59. |
[9] | 史蔚. 企业合规人员不作为刑事责任探析[J]. 法学家, 2022(5): 87-101+193-194. |
[10] | 李本灿. 我国企业合规研究的阶段性梳理与反思[J]. 华东政法大学学报, 2021, 24(4): 121-137. |
[11] | 李本灿. 刑事合规的制度边界[J]. 法学论坛, 2020, 35(4): 138-148. |
[12] | 陈家林. 不作为的共同正犯问题研究[J]. 暨南学报(哲学社会科学版), 2007(5): 66-71+153-154. |
[13] | 姚诗. 不作为正犯与共犯之区分: 实践发现与理论形塑[J]. 法学家, 2020(4): 114-127+194-195. |
[14] | 李志恒. 不作为参与理论的反思与构建[J]. 苏州大学学报(法学版), 2017, 4(3): 101-113. |
[15] | 黎宏. 不阻止他人犯罪的刑事责任[J]. 中国法学, 2020(4): 201-221. |
[16] | 欧阳本祺. 论不作为正犯与共犯的区分[J]. 中外法学, 2015, 27(3): 717-738. |
[17] | 敬力嘉. 单位犯罪刑事归责中数据合规师的作为义务[J]. 北方法学, 2021, 15(6): 97-108. |