|
人格否认背景下夫妻股东责任问题研究
|
Abstract:
“夫妻公司”因其股东之间不可避免的夫妻关系,在经营过程中,容易出现人格否认问题。本文在“夫妻公司”人格否认背景下,首先通过比较个人独资企业说、合伙企业说、一人公司说以及有限责任公司说等学说的优缺点,从而明确“夫妻公司”的性质;其次,通过梳理夫妻股东的出资来源,分路径对出资分别来自夫妻共同财产或/和夫妻私有财产的情形进行讨论,通过结合夫妻股东的主观意图,明确在人格否认背景下,公司股东的出资来源不同时,夫妻股东的责任应当作何划分的问题;最后通过立法、司法、行政和完善内部制度方面,规范“夫妻公司”的运营模式,明确股东责任范围,以此减少债权人风险,保护债权人的利益。
Because of the inevitable conjugal relationship between the shareholders, “husband and wife company” is prone to personality denial in the course of operation. Under the background of personality denial of “husband and wife company”, this paper first makes clear the nature of “husband and wife company” by comparing the advantages and disadvantages of theories such as sole proprietorship, partnership, one-person company and limited liability company. Secondly, by sorting out the sources of capital contribution of the husband and wife shareholders, the paper discusses the situation that the capital contribution comes from the husband and wife’s common property or/and the husband and wife’s private property in different ways. By combining the subjective intention of the husband and wife shareholders, it makes clear how to divide the responsibilities of the husband and wife shareholders when the sources of capital contribution of the company shareholders are different under the background of personality denial. Finally, through legislation, judicature, administration and internal system improvement, the operation mode of “husband and wife company” is standardized, and the scope of shareholders’ responsibility is clarified, so as to reduce the risk of creditors and protect the interests of creditors.
[1] | 丰琼英. 夫妻公司人格否认制度[J]. 中国市场, 2021(27): 99-100. |
[2] | 顾敏康. 反思公司法的几个基石问题[J]. 法学, 2013(5): 80-86. |
[3] | 邓立立. 夫妻公司人格否认实证研究[D]: [硕士学位论文]. 成都: 西南财经大学, 2020. |
[4] | 朱小东. 论一人公司人格否认制度——基于厦门电力投资公司贷款纠纷一案的法律评析[D]: [硕士学位论文]. 重庆: 西南政法大学, 2010. |
[5] | 杨柳. 夫妻公司是否属于一人公司?——基于司法态度嬗变的反思[J]. 宜宾学院学报, 2022, 22(8): 24-32. |
[6] | 王宇楷. “夫妻公司”财产混同证明责任分配争议与分析[J]. 广西质量监督导报, 2021(1): 237-239+226. |
[7] | 张霞明. 夫妻公司若干法律问题的案例分析[D]: [硕士学位论文]. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2016. |
[8] | 赵冰. “夫妻公司”债务承担中的人格否认问题研究[D]: [硕士学位论文]. 长沙: 湖南师范大学, 2020. |
[9] | 李俊. 论离婚时有限责任公司夫妻准共有股权之分割[J]. 人民司法, 2006(9): 68-72. |
[10] | 刘陈悦. 谭利兴诉黎经炜等股东利益损害赔偿纠纷案评析[D]: [硕士学位论文]. 长沙: 湖南大学, 2018. |
[11] | 刘辛志. 夫妻公司类推适用一人公司举证规则探析[J]. 北京政法职业学院学报, 2022(3): 30-35. |