|
行政诉讼中投诉人原告资格的认定
|
Abstract:
随着自由防御性行政法转变为利害调整性行政法,行政机关在解决民事争议过程中也发挥着重要的作用。当受害者遭受非源自国家的侵害时,可以通过投诉的方式请求行政机关介入维权。当投诉人对行政机关处理的结果不满意或者行政机关不作为时可以提起行政诉讼,投诉人是否具有原告资格以及诉讼请求能否被支持的问题由此产生。通过梳理裁判文书,司法裁判存在着对“利害关系”界定的不同、投诉与举报混用以及类案不同判的问题。以消费者投诉权为切入点,在界定投诉权性质的基础上,分析投诉权是否属于行政诉讼法所保护的合法权益、以明确行政法上投诉人原告资格的判定标准。
With the transformation of the free defensive administrative law into the interest adjustment law, the administrative organs in the process of resolving civil disputes also play an important role. When a victim suffers an attack that does not originate from the state, he or she can request the administrative authorities to intervene to protect his or her rights through a complaint. When the complainant is not satisfied with the result of handling by the administrative organ or the administrative organ does not act, he can file an administrative lawsuit. Therefore, the question of whether the complainant has the plaintiff qualification and whether the lawsuit request can be supported arises. Through sorting out the judgment documents, there are problems of different definition of “interest relationship”, mixed use of complaint and report, and different judgment of different cases. Starting from the consumer’s right to complain, on the basis of defining the nature of the right to complain, the paper analyzes whether the right to complain belongs to the legitimate rights and interests protected by the administrative procedure law, so as to clarify the judgment standard of the complainant’s plaintiff’s qualification in the administrative law.
[1] | 李策. 行政投诉案件中原告资格的本土逻辑与实践反思[J]. 行政法学研究, 2022(1): 146-157. |
[2] | 罗仙凤. 《行诉解释》中投诉举报人原告资格条款的法解释学分析[J]. 法律方法, 2020(2): 273-286. |
[3] | 刘芳. 行政举报投诉人原告资格之判定逻辑与理论证成[J]. 甘肃政法大学学报, 2021(6): 146-155. |
[4] | 赵宏. 保护规范理论在举报投诉人原告资格中的适用[J]. 北京航空航天大学学报(社会科学版), 2018(5): 9-17. |
[5] | 李年清. 主观公权利、保护规范理论与行政诉讼中原告资格的判定——基于(2017)最高法行申169号刘广明案分析[J]. 法律适用(司法案例), 2019(2): 46-57. |
[6] | [德]哈姆雷特?毛雷尔. 行政法学总论[M]. 高家伟, 译. 北京: 法律出版社, 2000: 155. |
[7] | 黄涧秋. 举报答复行为可诉性的类型分析[J]. 法治研究, 2017(4): 152-160. |
[8] | 李凌云. 行政诉讼中投诉人与举报人的原告资格之区分[J]. 辽宁大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2022(1): 108-117. |
[9] | 黄铠. 行政诉讼中举报人原告资格的审查路径——基于指导案例77号的分析[J]. 政治与法律, 2017(10): 138-149. |