A Disagreement of Ownership: Three Books Between Sulayman Hilmi Tunahan and Muhammed ？hsan O？uz

Sulayman Hilmi Tunahan and Muhammad Ihsan Oghuz are two important figures and have become distinguished in the aspects of training student (tadr？s) and writing works (talif) respectively. In our recent history, almost identical three works have been attributed to both of them. The works, which are called as Mektuplar ve Baz？ Mesail-i Mühimme (The Letters and the Different Kind of Important Subjects) and Risala-i Kibr？t-i Ahmar are published by both Sulaimanian Group and Oghuz Puplications in the name of Sulayman Hilmi Tunahan and Muhammad Ihsan Oghuz respectively. Also, these works are used by the community of Sulaimanian in their conservation, readings and education system as a gift to the students who have graduated from their educational institutions. Although Risala-i Iks？r-i Ul？m we Ma’rifat have not been published by Oghuz Publications yet, the administrators of Oghuz Foundation and Oghuz’s heir have claimed that this work is in their hands. This article aims to determine that the works belong to whom we mentioned by taking advantage of some of the expressions in their texts and numerous factors outside of the text. As a result of our research, we came to conclusion that the works belong to Oghuz and probably these works were attributed to Tunahan wrongly