The Value of a Treatise Attributed to Pīr Me？med with Respect to the Discipline of Islamic Jurisprudence

In a treatise attributed to Pīr Mehmed, one of the scholars of ？slamic Jurisprudence and linguistics of the Ottoman period, there is a section in which some objections and assumptions, which are selected from a chapter titled as ‘order’ of Ibn Malak’s work called ？ar？ alManār, are answered and criticized. With the content analysis of this section, it is possible to underline the importance of aforementioned treatise in the literature of ？slamic Jurisprudence and to reach some data which determine or influence the opinions about the competence of the author. The aim of this study is to identify these data and to transform them into a general conclusion. In this sense, each of the methodological discussions in the treatise is dealt with specifically, and the internal consistency of the author's explanations after the short introductions of these discussions is examined. These explanations, which are tried to be determined according to widespread views in ？anafī method, are also compared with the information in some other ？ar？ and ？ā？iya written for the works, ？ar？ al-Manār and Manār al-anwār. It is also envisaged that this study, which includes not only the name, identity, and style of the treatise but also some suggestions and notes related to the content of the chapters that are outside the research area, may provide concrete contributions to the relevant parts of the comprehensive and in-depth research which is conducted on the author’s both scientific personality and his Work