|
- 2018
Validity of the Titmus Vision Screener: A Comparison With the Snellen Chart - Validity of the Titmus Vision Screener: A Comparison With the Snellen Chart - Open Access PubAbstract: Given limited knowledge regarding validity of the Titmus vision screener, we sought to compare visual acuity measurements obtained from the Titmus with that from the Snellen chart and assess the validity properties of the Titmus as a screening instrument to detect vision impairment. Visual acuity was measured in 150 participants recruited from an academic ophthalmology practice, using the Snellen chart as well as the Titmus vision screener. Visual acuities from the Titmus and Snellen were compared and validity of the Titmus vision screener was assessed by computing sensitivity and specificity. Using Snellen visual acuity as the reference standard, the sensitivity of the Titmus vision screener to detect vision impairment, defined as visual acuity worse than 20/40, was 92% (95% CI (72.5, 98.6)) and the specificity was 64% (95% CI (57.9, 70.1)). Comparisons of the precise visual acuity level revealed poor agreement between the two methods (weighted Kappa: 0.15, 95% CI (0.08, 0.21)). Visual acuities obtained from the Titmus were, on average, two lines worse than Snellen visual acuities. ((logMAR Snellen – logMAR Titmus) = - 0.19 ± 0.29, 95% confidence interval (CI) (-0.23, -0.16)). Titmus vision screener is a sensitive tool to detect visual impairment. However high false positive results and poor agreement with Snellen limits its widespread use in clinical applications. DOI10.14302/issn.2470-0436.jos-19-2693 Vision impairment (VI) affects 191 million people globally, mostly due to treatable or preventable causes 1. VI is associated with a wide range of adverse outcomes including poor quality of life, worse functioning and detrimental impact on mental health 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. Vision screening is an important public health measure to address the burden of VI. In addition to identifying correctable refractive error, vision screening is the first step in diagnosing more serious conditions, such as cataract, age-related macular degeneration, diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma, which are often asymptomatic in early stages and can benefit from treatment. There are numerous charts and methods used for visual acuity (VA) testing. The most commonly performed VA test in the eye care setting is the Snellen test, which requires a well-lit Snellen chart situated 20 feet (6 meters) or equivalent from the patient. Vision screening is also routinely performed in other settings including primary care clinics, occupational health screening, school health clinics, and vision testing for driver licensing. Space and lighting requirements for testing vision are factors limiting the
|