|
- 2018
滨海地区土壤盐分空间分布预测方法比较研究
|
Abstract:
以天津滨海地区为例, 利用4种确定性方法(反距离权重、径向基函数、全局多项式、局部多项式)和5种地统计方法(普通克里格、协同克里格、泛克里格、指示克里格、序贯高斯模拟)对典型样区进行土壤盐分空间分布估计、土壤盐渍化风险区域识别及其不确定性评价, 并针对不同方法的预测效果进行了综合对比分析.结果表明:地统计方法的插值精度整体上优于确定性方法, 序贯高斯模拟具有相对最高的预测精度; 模拟结果的统计特征与实测数据的一致性较高, 预测表面对局部细节的反映能力较强; 在以含盐量0.6% 为阈值的土壤盐分含量不确定性评估中, 序贯高斯模拟可通过多次模拟实现将环境风险性定量化, 是科学管理滨海地区盐渍化土壤资源的有效手段.
Focused on Tianjin coastal area,four deterministic methods(inverse distance weighting,radial basis functions,global polynomial interpolation and local polynomial interpolation)and five geostatistical interpolation methods(ordinary kriging,co-kriging,universal kriging,indicator kriging and sequential Gaussian simulation)were applied to estimate the spatial distribution of soil salinity of a typical sample area,identify risky areas of soil salinization and evaluate outcomes’ uncertainty. On this basis,the paper carried out comparative analyses according to the forecast effects of different methods. Results show that on the whole,the interpolation precision of geostatistical interpolation methods is higher than that of deterministic methods and sequential Gaussian simulation has relatively the highest prediction accuracy. Statistical features of simulation results and the measured data are of high consistency,and the interpolation surface of sequential Gaussian simulation can reflect the local details accurately. Furthermore,in the uncertainty assessment with the threshold of soil salt content at 0.6% ,sequential Gaussian simulation can quantify the environmental risk through multiple simulations. It is an effective?measure to manage saline soil resources in coastal areas scientifically
[1] | 徐恒刚. 中国盐生植被及盐渍化生态治理[M]. 北京:中国农业科学技术出版社, 2004. |
[2] | Sauer T J, Meek D W. Spatial variation of plant-available phosphorus in pastures with contrasting management[J]. <i>Soil Science Society of America Journal</i>, 2003, 67(3):826-836. |
[3] | Ma Chengxia, Ding Jianli, Wang Lu, et al. Research for interpolation method of spatial variation analysis on soil salinity in the oasis[J]. <i>Research of Soil and Water Conservation</i>, 2014(4):317-320(in Chinese). |
[4] | Chen F W, Liu C W. Estimation of the spatial rainfall distribution using inverse distance weighting(IDW)in the middle of Taiwan[J]. <i>Paddy and Water Environment</i>, 2012, 10(3):209-222. |
[5] | Li H Y, Shi Z, Webster R, et al. Mapping the three-dimensional variation of soil salinity in a rice-paddy soil [J]. <i>Geoderma</i>, 2013, 195:31-41. |
[6] | 王红, 刘高焕, 宫鹏. 利用Cokriging提高估算土壤盐离子浓度分布的精度――以黄河三角洲为例[J]. 地理学报, 2005, 60(3):511-518. |
[7] | Wang Hong, Liu Gaohuan, Gong Peng. Use of cokriging to improve estimates of soil salt solute spatial distribution in the Yellow River Delta[J]. <i>Acta Geographica Sinica</i>, 2005, 60(3):511-518(in Chinese). |
[8] | 杨奇勇, 杨劲松, 余世鹏. 禹城市耕地土壤盐分与有机质的指示克里格分析[J]. 生态学报, 2011, 31(8):2196-2202. |
[9] | 史文娇, 岳天祥, 石晓丽, 等. 土壤连续属性空间插值方法及其精度的研究进展[J]. 自然资源学报, 2012, 27(1):163-175. |
[10] | Guo Huaicheng, Zhou Feng, Dao Xu. State-of-art on geostatistical methodology[J]. <i>Geographical Research</i>, 2008, 27(5):1191-1202(in Chinese). |
[11] | Pendrel J, Leggett M, Mesdag P. Geostatistical simulation for reservoir characterization[C]//2004 <i>CSEG National Convention.<i> Calgary, Canada, 2004. |
[12] | 赵彦锋, 化全县, 陈杰. Kriging 插值和序贯高斯条件模拟的原理比较及在土壤空间变异研究中的案例分析[J]. 土壤学报, 2011, 48(4):856-862. |
[13] | 易湘生, 李国胜, 尹衍雨, 等. 土壤厚度的空间插值方法比较――以青海三江源地区为例[J]. 地理研究, 2012, 31(10):1793-1805. |
[14] | Yi Xiangsheng, Li Guosheng, Yin Yanyu, et al. Comparison on soil depth prediction among different spatial interpolation methods:A case study in the Three-River |
[15] | 吴春生, 黄?, 刘高焕, 等. 黄河三角洲土壤含盐量空间预测方法研究[J]. 资源科学, 2016, 38(4):704-713. |
[16] | Wu Chunsheng, Huang Chong, Liu Gaohuan, et al. Spatial prediction of soil salinity in the Yellow River Delta based on geographically weighted regression[J]. <i>Resources Science</i>, 2016, 38(4):704-713(in Chinese). |
[17] | Cambardella C A, Moorman T B, Parkin T B, et al. Field-scale variability of soil properties in central Iowa soils[J]. <i>Soil Science Society of America Journal</i>, 1994, 58(5):1501-1511. |
[18] | Zhang Guofeng, Qu Mingkai, Cheng Zhaojin, et al. Assessment for spatial uncertainty of daily minimum temperature by using sequential Gaussian simulation[J]. <i>Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology</i>, 2014, 25(1):117-124(in Chinese). |
[19] | 孙向阳. 土壤学[M]. 北京:中国林业出版社, 2005. |
[20] | Sun Xiangyang. <i>Soil Science</i>[M]. Beijing:China Forestry Press, 2005(in Chinese). |
[21] | 张国峰, 瞿明凯, 成兆金, 等. 基于序贯高斯模拟的日最低气温空间不确定性评估[J]. 应用生态学报, 2014, 25(1):117-124. |
[22] | 赵彦锋, 孙志英, 陈杰. Kriging 插值和序贯高斯条件模拟算法的对比分析[J]. 地球信息科学学报, 2011, 12(6):767-776. |
[23] | Li Yongzhi, Shan Fengxiang. The analysis of soil salinization hazards and governance approaches[J]. <i>West-China Exploration Engineering</i>, 2008, 20(8):85-88(in Chinese). |
[24] | Zhu Huiyi, Liu Shulin, Jia Shaofeng. Problems of the spatial interpolation of physical geographical elements [J]. <i>Geographical Research</i>, 2004, 23(4):425-432(in Chinese). |
[25] | 魏俊奇, 李小雁, 蒋志云, 等. 基于 EMI 的小泊湖退化湿地土壤盐分的空间分布[J]. 水土保持学报, 2016(6):284-288. |
[26] | Wei Junqi, Li Xiaoyan, Jiang Zhiyun, et al. Spatial distribution of soil salinity in a degraded wetland of Xiaopo Lake based on EMI[J]. <i>Journal of Soil and Water Conservation</i>, 2016(6):284-288(in Chinese). |
[27] | Yu J, Li Y, Han G, et al. The spatial distribution characteristics of soil salinity in coastal zone of the Yellow River Delta[J]. <i>Environmental Earth Sciences</i>, 2014, 72(2):589-599. |
[28] | 马成霞, 丁建丽, 王璐, 等. 绿洲土壤表层含盐量空间变异分析的插值方法研究[J]. 水土保持研究, 2014(4):317-320. |
[29] | 郭怀成, 周丰, 刀?. 地统计方法学研究进展[J]. 地理研究, 2008, 27(5):1191-1202. |
[30] | Zhao Yongcun, Shi Xuezheng, Yu Dongsheng, et al. Different methods for prediction of spatial patterns of soil organic carbon density in Hebei province, China[J]. <i>Acta Pedologica Sinica</i>, 2005, 42(3):379-385(in Chinese). |
[31] | Zhao Yanfeng, Hua Quanxian, Chen Jie. Comparison of kriging interpolation with conditional sequential Gaussian simulation in principles and case analysis of their application in study on soil spatial variation[J]. <i>Acta Pedologica Sinica</i>, 2011, 48(4):856-862(in Chinese). |
[32] | Li J, Heap A D. A review of comparative studies of spatial interpolation methods in environmental sciences:Performance and impact factors[J]. <i>Ecological Informatics</i>, 2011, 6(3):228-241. |
[33] | Headwaters region of Qinghai province[J]. <i>Geographical Research</i>, 2012, 31(10):1793-1805(in Chinese). |
[34] | Chiles J P, Delfiner P. <i>Geostatistics</i>:<i>Modeling Spatial Uncertainty</i>[M]. America:John Wiley & Sons, 2009. |
[35] | 王遵亲, 祝寿泉, 俞仁培. 中国盐渍土[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 1993. |
[36] | Wang Zunqin, Zhu Shouquan, Yu Renpei. <i>Saline Soil in China</i>[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 1993(in Chinese). |
[37] | 李永智, 单风翔. 土壤盐渍化危害及治理途径浅析[J]. 西部探矿工程, 2008, 20(8):85-88. |
[38] | Lü Z Z, Liu G M, Yang J S, et al. Spatial variability of soil salinity in Bohai Sea coastal wetlands, China:Partition into four management zones[J]. <i>Plant Biosystems―An International Journal Dealing with all Aspects of Plant Biology</i>, 2013, 147(4):1201-1210. |
[39] | Xu Henggang. <i>Chinese Saline Vegetation and Salinization Ecological Governance</i>[M]. Beijing:China Agricultural Science and Technology Press, 2004(in Chinese). |
[40] | 朱会义, 刘述林, 贾绍凤. 自然地理要素空间插值的几个问题[J]. 地理研究, 2004, 23(4):425-432. |
[41] | Yang Qiyong, Yang Jinsong, Yu Shipeng. Evaluation on spatial distribution of soil salinity and soil organic matter by indicator kriging in Yucheng City[J]. <i>Acta Ecologica Sinica</i>, 2011, 31(8):2196-2202(in Chinese). |
[42] | Shi Wenjiao, Yue Tianxiang, Shi Xiaoli, et al. Research progress in soil property interpolators and their accuracy[J]. <i>Journal of Natural Resources</i>, 2012, 27(1):163-175(in Chinese). |
[43] | 姚荣江, 杨劲松, 韩建均. 海涂围垦区土壤盐分空间变异模拟的比较研究[J]. 土壤学报, 2012, 49(2):275-281. |
[44] | Yao Rongjiang, Yang Jinsong, Han Jianjun. Comparative study of simulations of spatial variability of soil salinity in coastal polders[J]. <i>Acta Pedologica Sinica</i>, 2012, 49(2):275-281(in Chinese). |
[45] | Yao Xueling, Fu Bojie, Lü Yihe, et al. Comparison of four spatial interpolation methods for estimating soil moisture in a complex terrain catchment[J]. <i>PloS One</i>, 2013, 8(1):e54660. |
[46] | 汤国安, 杨昕. ArcGIS 地理信息系统空间分析实验教程[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 2006. |
[47] | Tang Guoan, Yang Xin. <i>ArcGIS Geographic Information System Spatial Analysis Experiment Tutorial</i>[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 2006(in Chinese). |
[48] | Zou Y L, Hu F L, Zhou C C, et al. Analysis of radial basis function interpolation approach[J]. <i>Applied Geophysics</i>, 2013, 10(4):397. |
[49] | 赵永存, 史学正, 于东升, 等. 不同方法预测河北省土壤有机碳密度空间分布特征的研究[J]. 土壤学报, 2005, 42(3):379-385. |
[50] | Zhao Yanfeng, Sun Zhiying, Chen Jie. Analysis and comparison in arithmetic for kriging interpolation and sequential Gaussian conditional simulation[J]. <i>Journal of Geo-Information Science</i>, 2011, 12(6):767-776(in Chinese).</i></i> |