|
|
- 2015
领导-下属互动机制的本土建构
|
Abstract:
基于研究者自身的成长经历、组织经验及社会观察，建构了一个阐释领导与下属互动机制的本土模型，并对几种典型的组织（社会）现象形成机理进行了剖析。研究认为：在中国当下的组织（社会）情境中，领导与下属互动关系的改善，首先需要激发下属(领导)个体自我意识效应以及对两种认知错误的抑制；其次需要个体自我意识的群体化扩展，以有效抵抗领导的决策错误和下属的错误行为；最后，长期而言，只有社会化重塑才能深层次地改变中国本土领导与下属的信念、认知和行为，从而尽可能规避不断反复的组织（社会）危机。
Drawing on the researcher′s personal growth,organizational experience and their observation on society,the paper constructs an indigenous model of interactive mechanism of the leader and the followers,which could offer a deep interpretation on several organizational (social) phenomena.The author argues,for the sake of cooperation between the leaders and the followers in Chinese context,firstly,we need to trigger the followers′（leaders′）individual self-awareness effect and to inhibit their two kinds of misconceptions when they work together,secondly,we need to transfer the individual self-awareness effect into the collective consensus that could help us to reject the leaders′ wrong decisions and followers′ wrong doings,finally,in the long run,only if we reshape our socialized process so as to change the Chinese mind-set and behavior pattern of the leader and the follower,we can find the ways to avoid the recurrent organizational (social) crisis as far as possible
| [1] | ［5］OC B，BASHSHUR M R.Followership,leadership and social influence［J］.The Leadership Quarterly，2013，24（6）：919-934. |
| [2] | ［8］BAKER S D.Followership:the theoretical foundation of a contemporary construct［J］.Journal of Leadership and Organizational Studies，2007，14(1):50-60. |
| [3] | ［9］THOROUGHGOOD C N，HUNTER S T，SAWYER K B.Bad apples,bad barrels,and broken followers? An empirical examination of contextual influences on follower perceptions and reactions to aversive leadership［J］.Journal of Business Ethics，2011,100(4):647-672. |
| [4] | ［10］UHL-BIEN M，RIGGIO R E，LOWE K B，et al.Followership theory:A review and research agenda［J］.The Leadership Quarterly，2014，25（1）:83-104. |
| [5] | ［12］MORRISON E W，MILLIKEN F J.Organizational silence:a barrier to change and development in a pluralistic world［J］.Academy of Management Review，2000，25(4):706-725. |
| [6] | ［26］韦尔策.社会记忆：历史，回忆，传承［M］.季斌，王立君，白锡？遥？译.北京：北京大学出版社，2007：179-194. |
| [7] | ［27］韩巍.学术探讨中的措辞及表达：谈《创建中国特色管理学的基本问题之管见》［J］，管理学报，2005，2(4):386-391. |
| [8] | ［28］韩巍.从批判性和建设性的视角看“管理学在中国”［J］.管理学报，2008，5(2):161-168. |
| [9] | ［29］韩巍.珍惜学术表达的自由：对《出路与展望：直面中国管理实践》的响应与批评［J］.管理学报，2011，8(3):365-370. |
| [10] | ［1］Van VUGT M，HOGAN R，KAISER R B.Leadership,Followership,and Evolution［J］.American Psycologist，2008，63(3):182-196. |
| [11] | ［2］韩巍，席酉民.不确定性-支配权-本土化领导理论：和谐管理的视角［J］.西安交通大学学报：社会科学版，2009，29 (5):7-17. |
| [12] | ［3］席酉民，韩巍.中国管理学界的困境和出路：本土化领导研究思考的启示［J］.西安交通大学学报：社会科学版，2010，30(2):32-40. |
| [13] | ［13］CARSTEN M K，UHL-BIEN M，WEST B J，et al.Exploring social constructions of followership:A qualitative study［J］.The Leadership Quarterly，2010，21（3）:543-562. |
| [14] | ［15］CROSSMAN B，CROSSMAN J.Conceptualising followership-a review of the literature［J］.Leadership，2011，7(4):481-497. |
| [15] | ［16］ALVESSON M.Leadership studies:From procedure and abstraction to reflexivity and situation［J］.Leadership Quarterly,1996，7(4),455-485. |
| [16] | ［17］韩巍.论实证研究神塔的倒掉［J］.管理学报，2011，8(7):980-989. |
| [17] | ［22］伽达默尔.真理与方法［M］.洪汉鼎，译.北京:商务印书馆，2007：24-26. |
| [18] | ［23］PARRY K，MUMFORD M D，BOWER I，et al.Qualitative and historiometric methods in leadership research:A review of the first 25 years of The Leadership Quarterly［J］.The Leadership Quarterly，2014,25(1):132-151. |
| [19] | ［45］PIVEN F F.Can Power from below Change the World? ［J］.American Sociological Review，2008，73(1):1-14. |
| [20] | ［11］DERUE D S，ASHFORD S J.Who will lead and who will follow a social process of leadership identity in organization［J］.Academy of Management Review，2010，35(4):627-647. |
| [21] | ［18］韩巍，席酉民.自我呈现与反思：组织管理研究的一种补缺性方法论［J］.西安交通大学学报：社会科学版，2009，29(3):31-38. |
| [22] | ［24］ALVESSON M，SVENINGSSON S.The great disappearing act:difficulties in doing ’’leadership’’［J］.The Leadership Quarterly，2003，14(3):359-381. |
| [23] | ［25］HAWKINS M A，SALEEM F Z.The omnipresent personal narrative:story formulation and the interplay among narratives［J］.Journal of Organizational Change Management，2012，25(2):204-219. |
| [24] | ［30］韩巍.管理研究认识论的探索:基于“管理学在中国”专题论文的梳理及反思［J］.管理学报，2011，8(12):1772-1781. |
| [25] | ［31］韩巍.学术评价的回归及业绩管理的矫正［J］.西安交通大学学报：社会科学版， 2014，34(3):8-17. |
| [26] | ［32］AUVINEN T P，LAMSA A M，SINTONEN T,et al.Leadership Manipulation and ethics in storytelling［J］.Journal of business ethics，2013，116（2）:415-431. |
| [27] | ［33］伯基特.社会性自我［M］.李康，译.北京:北京大学出版社，2012. |
| [28] | ［43］伯格，卢克曼.现实的社会建构［M］.汪涌，译.北京：北京大学出版社，2009：1-16. |
| [29] | ［37］李汉林.中国单位社会：议论，思考与研究［M］.上海:上海人民出版社，2004：62. |
| [30] | ［38］TEPPER B J.Consequences of abusive supervision［J］.Academy of Management Journal,2000,43(2):178-190. |
| [31] | ［39］福柯.规训与惩罚［M］.刘北成，杨远婴，译.北京:生活？读书？新知三联出版社，2012：337-354. |
| [32] | ［40］GARDNER W L，AVOLIO B J，LUTHANS F,et al."Can you see the real me?" A self-based model of authentic leader and follower development［J］.The Leadership Quarterly，2005，16:343-372. |
| [33] | ［41］杨中芳.如何研究中国人［M］.重庆：重庆大学出版社，2009：200. |
| [34] | ［42］COURPASSON D，DANY F.Indifference or Obedience? Business Firms as Democratic Hybrids［J］.Organization Studies，2003，24(8):1231-1260. |
| [35] | ［44］ASTLEY W G.Administrative Science As Socially Constructed Truth［J］.Administrative Science Quarterly，1985，30(4):497-513. |
| [36] | ［46］林毓生.中国传统的创造性转化［M］.北京:生活？读书？新知三联出版社，1988:324-330. |
| [37] | ［4］韩巍，席酉民.机会型领导，幻觉型领导：两个中国本土领导的关键构念［J］.管理学报，2012，9(12):1725-1734. |
| [38] | ［6］COLLINSON D.Rethinking followership:a post-structuralist analysis of follower identities［J］.Leadership Quarterly，2006，17(2) :179-189. |
| [39] | ［7］Van VUGT M.Evolutionary origins of leadership and followership［J］.Personality and Social Psychology Review，2006，10(4):354-371. |
| [40] | ［14］WERHANE P H，HARTMAN L P，MOBERG D，et al.Social constructivism,mental models,and problems of obedience［J］.Journal of Business Ethics，2011，100（1）:103-118. |
| [41] | ［19］BOJE D M，OSWICK C，FORD J D.Language and Organization:The Doing of Discourse［J］.Academy of Management Review，2004，29(4):571-577. |
| [42] | ［20］SPARROWE R T.Authentic leadership and the narrative self［J］.The Leadership Quarterly，2005，16 (3):419-439. |
| [43] | ［21］韩巍.管理学界应该接纳思辨研究［J］.管理学家：学术版，2011，4(7):23-36. |
| [44] | ［34］BARBUTO J E.Influence triggers:a framework for understanding follower compliance［J］.Leadership Quaterly，2000，11(3):365-387. |
| [45] | ［35］朱迪斯.权力的精神生活：服从的理论［M］.张生，译.南京:江苏人民出版社，2009：7. |
| [46] | ［36］阿伦森.社会性动物［M］.邢占军，译.上海：华东师范大学出版社，2007：9-41. |
