|
|
- 2015
破解渠道投机的恶性循环：合同治理与关系治理权变模型
|
Abstract:
基于交易成本理论、关系契约理论与相互性理论，实证探讨了合同与关系规范对渠道投机行为及其相互性的影响。从制造商角度收集数据，采用层次回归分析发现：经销商的投机行为会加重制造商的投机行为（相互性）；经销商可以通过单独使用合同或关系规范减弱制造商的投机行为，也可以共同使用它们以达到更好的效果；不过在抑制渠道投机相互性方面，只有共同使用合同与关系规范才能将其有效减弱，减弱的效果随不同的组合水平而定。
Based on the theories of transaction cost,relational contract and reciprocity,we empirically examine the impacts of contract and relational norms on channel opportunism as well as its reciprocity. We collect the data from the angle of manufactures and adopt the hierarchical regression analysis,finding that suppliers′ opportunist behavior aggravates manufactures′ opportunist behavior (reciprocity);suppliers can not only employ either contract or relational norms to mitigate manufactures′ opportunist behavior,but also simultaneously apply these two governance mechanisms to achieve better effects. However,reciprocity of channel opportunism can only be effectively weakened when contract and relational norms are both employed and the weakening effectiveness is dependent on different combinations of these two governance mechanisms
| [1] | ［14］CANNON J P,ACHROL R S,GUNDLACH G T.Contracts,Norms,and Plural Form Governance ［J］.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2000，28(2)：180-194. |
| [2] | ［15］BRUNI L,GILLI M,PELLIGRA V.Reciprocity：Theory and Facts Introduction to the Special Issue［J］.International Review of Economics,2008，1(2)：1-11. |
| [3] | ［17］NEUERT J,BUTIN J,FARFELAN A S,et al.Rational Conduct,Fairness,and Reciprocity in Economic Transaction Processes ［J］.Journal of American Academy of Business,2005，7(1)：338-353. |
| [4] | ［18］WILLIAMSON OE.The Mechanisms of Governance ［M］.Oxford：Oxford University Press，1996：212-230. |
| [5] | ［19］JAP S D,GANESAN S.Control Mechanisms and the Relationship Life Cycle：Implications for Safeguarding Specific Investments and Developing Commitment ［J］.Journal of Marketing Research,2000，37(2)：227-245. |
| [6] | ［20］KASHLAK R,CHANDRAN R,BENEDETTO C A D.Reciprocity in International Business：A Study of Telecommunications Alliances and Contracts ［J］.Journal of International Business Studies,1998，29(2)：281-304. |
| [7] | ［24］LUSCH R F,BROWN J R.Interdependency,Contracting,and Relational Behavior in Marketing Channels ［J］.Journal of Marketing,1996,60(4)：19-38. |
| [8] | ［25］GUNDLACH G T,ACHROL R S,MENTZER J T.The Structure of Commitment in Exchange ［J］.Journal of Marketing,1995，59(1)：78-92. |
| [9] | ［27］LINDELL M K,WHITNEY D J.Accounting for Common Method Variance in Cross-Sectional Research Designs ［J］.Journal of Applied Psychology,2001，86(1)：114-121. |
| [10] | ［29］ACHROL R S,GUNDLACH G T.Legal and Social Safeguards Against Opportunism in Exchange ［J］.Journal of Retailing,1999，75(1)：107-124. |
| [11] | ［10］GOO J,KISHORE R,RAO H R,et al.The Role of Service Level Agreements in Relational Management of Information Technology Outsourcing：An Empirical Study ［J］.MIS Quarterly,2009，33(1)：119-145. |
| [12] | ［13］YANG Z,ZHOU C,JIANG L.When Do Formal Control and Trust Matter? A Context-Based Analysis of the Effects on Marketing Channel Relationships in China ［J］.Industrial Marketing Management,2011，40(1)：86-96. |
| [13] | ［21］REUBEN E,WINDEN F V.Negative Reciprocity and the Interaction of Emotions and Fairness Norms ［R］.CESifo Working Paper Series,2005，No.1685. |
| [14] | ［22］ANTIA K D,FRAZIER G L.The Severity of Contract Enforcement in Interfirm Channel Relationships ［J］.Journal of Marketing,2001，65(4)：67-81. |
| [15] | ［23］KAUFMANN P J,STERN L W.Relational Exchange Norms,Perceptions of Unfairness,and Retained Hostility in Commercial Litigation ［J］.Journal of Conflict Resolution,1988，32(3)：534-552. |
| [16] | ［28］JACCARD J,TURRISI R.Interaction Effects in Multiple Regression ［M］.Thousand Oaks,CA：Sage,2003：45-60. |
| [17] | ［2］BROWN J R,DEV C S,LEE D.Managing Marketing Channel Opportunism：The Efficacy of Alternative Governance Mechanisms ［J］.Journal of Marketing,2000,64(2)：51-65. |
| [18] | ［3］WATHNE K H,HEIDE J B.Opportunism in Interfirm Relationships：Forms,Outcomes,and Solutions ［J］.Journal of Marketing,2000，64(4)：36-51. |
| [19] | ［4］庄贵军,刘宇.渠道投机行为的相互性以及交易专有资产的影响［J］.管理科学，2010(6):43-52. |
| [20] | ［5］HEIDE J B.Interorganizational Governance in Marketing Channels ［J］.Journal of Marketing,1994，58：71-85. |
| [21] | ［6］WILLIAMSON O E.Markets and Hierarchies ［M］.New York：The Free Press，1975：30. |
| [22] | ［7］周茵，庄贵军，彭茜.关系型治理何时能够抑制渠道投机行为？――企业间关系质量调节作用的实证检验［J］.管理评论，2013 (1):90-100. |
| [23] | ［8］STINCHCOMBE A L.Contracts as Hierarchical Documents［C］// STINCHCOMBE A L,HEIMER C.Organization Theory and Project Management.Bergen：Norwegian University Press，1985：121-171. |
| [24] | ［9］MACNEIL I R.The New Social Contract ［M］.New Haven,CT：Yale University Press，1980：20. |
| [25] | ［11］POPPO L,ZENGER T.Do Formal Contracts and Relational Governance Function as Substitutes or Complements? ［J］Strategic Management Journal,2002，23(8)：707-725. |
| [26] | ［12］WUYTS S,GEYSKENS I.The Formation of Buyer-Supplier Relationships：Detailed Contract Drafting and Close Partner Selection ［J］.Journal of Marketing,2005，69：103-117. |
| [27] | ［1］HEIDE J B,JOHN G.Alliances in Industrial Purchasing：The Determinants of Joint Action in Buyer Supplier Relationships ［J］.Journal of Marketing Research,1990,27(1)：24-36. |
| [28] | ［16］FALK A,FISCHBACHER U.A Theory of Reciprocity ［J］.Games and Economic Behavior,2006，54 (2)：293-315. |
| [29] | ［26］GARVER M S,MEMTZER J T.Logistics Research Methods：Employing Structural Equation Modeling to Test for Construct Validity ［J］.Journal of Business Logistics,1999，20(1)：33-57. |
