|
|
- 2017
差序政府信任与政治体制支持
|
Abstract:
在调查数据基础上,实证研究了差序政府信任、反差序政府信任以及两类无差序政府信任是如何影响公民对现有政治体制的支持水平的。研究发现,对现有政治体制支持水平最高的是无差序政府信任(央地皆信)者,其次是差序政府信任者,再次是反差序政府信任者,最后是无差序政府信任(央地皆不信)者。研究认为差序政府信任作为一种策略,有效地阻滞了合法性危机的上移,保护了政治核心部门和政治体制的合法性。
Based on the data of the national survey conducted in 2011, this study explores how four types of political trust (hierarchical trust, paradoxical trust, equal trust, equal distrust) affect people′s regime support. The result reveals that the equal trust holders are the most active to become regime supporters, followed by the hierarchical trust holders, and then the paradoxical trust holders, and the equal distrust holders come to the last. I then argue that as a strategy the hierarchical trust successfully block legitimacy crisis transmit from grassroots to the high？？level government, and it also protect the legitimacy of political regime
| [1] | ［1］CALDEIRA G A, GIBSON J L. The Legitimacy of the Court of Justice in the European Union: Models of Institutional Support ［J］. American Political Science Review, 1995, 89: 356376. |
| [2] | ［2］CHEN J. Popular Political Support in Urban China ［M］. Washington: Woodrow Wilson Center Press, 2004: 2253, 179194. |
| [3] | ［13］ZHAO D. The Mandate of Heaven and Performance Legitimation in Historical and Contemporary China ［J］. American Behavioral Scientist, 2009, 53: 416433. |
| [4] | ［22］吕书鹏. 差序政府信任: 概念, 现状及成因――基于三次全国调查数据的实证研究 ［J］. 学海, 2015(4): 148157. |
| [5] | ［25］于建嵘. 抗争性政治: 中国政治社会学基本问题 ［M］. 北京: 人民出版社, 2010: 5160. |
| [6] | ［26］管？h. 政治信任的层级差异及其解释: 一项基于大学生群体的研究 ［J］. 公共行政评论, 2012(5): 6799. |
| [7] | ［27］肖唐镖, 王欣. 中国农民政治信任的变迁: 对五省份60个村的跟踪研究(1999―2008) ［J］. 管理世界, 2010(9): 8894. |
| [8] | ［28］李连江. 差序政府信任 ［J］. 二十一世纪, 2012(6):108114. |
| [9] | ［29］刘晖. 政府绩效对合法性水平层级差异的作用机制――中央政府与地方政府的比较 ［J］. 北京航空航天大学学报(社会科学版), 2007(1), 3437. |
| [10] | ［31］吕书鹏. 不同政府信任类型对公民政治参与的影响――基于第三波ABS数据的实证研究 ［J］. 华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2017(4): 3139. |
| [11] | ［7］MULLER E N, JUKAM T O, SELIGSON M A. Diffuse Political Support and Antisystem Political Behavior: A Comparative Analysis ［J］. American Journal of Political Science, 1982, 26: 240264. |
| [12] | ［8］LI L. Distrust in Government Leaders, Demand for Leadership Change, and Preference for Popular Elections in Rural China ［J］. Political Behavior, 2011, 33: 291311. |
| [13] | ［15］SHAMBAUGH D. China′s Communist Party: Atrophy and Adaptation ［M］. Washington: Woodrow Wilson Center Press and University of California Press, 2008: 110, 161182. |
| [14] | ［33］LI L. The Magnitude and Resilience of Trust in the Center Evidence from Interviews with Petitioners in Beijing and a Local Survey in Rural China ［J］. Modern China, 2013, 39: 336. |
| [15] | ［6］MULLER E N, JUKAM T O. On the Meaning of Political Support ［J］. American Political Science Review, 1977, 71: 15611595. |
| [16] | ［14］于建嵘. 从刚性稳定到韧性稳定――关于中国社会秩序的一个分析框架 ［J］. 学习与探索, 2009(5): 113118. |
| [17] | ［16］CHEN J, DICKSON B J. Allies of the State: Democratic Support and Regime Support Among China′s Private Entrepreneurs ［J］. The China Quarterly, 2008, 196: 780804. |
| [18] | ［17］TSAI K S. Capitalism without Democracy: The Private Sector in Contemporary China ［M］. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2007: 72104. |
| [19] | ［23］NYE J S. Introduction: The Decline of Confidence in Government ［M］∥NYE J S, ZELIKOW P D, KING D C. Why People Don′t Trust Government. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1997: 118. |
| [20] | ［24］张厚安, 蒙桂兰. 完善村民委员会的民主选举制度推进农村政治稳定与发展――湖北省广水市村民委员会换届选举调查 ［J］. 社会主义研究, 1993(4): 3843. |
| [21] | ［34］吕书鹏, 朱正威. 政府信任区域差异研究――基于对China Survey 2008数据的双层线性回归分析 ［J］. 公共行政评论, 2015(2): 125145. |
| [22] | ［3］CHEN J, ZHONG Y, HILLARD J W. The Level and Sources of Popular Support for China′s Current Political Regime ［J］. Communist and Post？？Communist Studies, 1997, 30: 4564. |
| [23] | ［4］LIPSET S M, SCHNEIDER W G. The Decline of Confidence in American Institutions ［J］. Political Science Quarterly, 1983, 98: 379402. |
| [24] | ［5］FINKEL S E, MULLER E N, SELIGSON M A. Economic Crisis, Incumbent Performance and Regime Support: A Comparison of Longitudinal Data from West Germany and Costa Rica ［J］. British Journal of Political Science, 1989, 19: 329351. |
| [25] | ［9］ZHONG Y, CHEN Y. Regime Support in Urban China ［J］. Asian Survey, 2013, 53: 369392. |
| [26] | ［10］EASTON D. A Systems Analysis of Political Life ［M］. New York: Wiley, 1965: 1736. |
| [27] | ［11］LIPSET S M. Political Man: The Social Bases of Politics ［M］. Garden City: Doubleday, 1963: 7796. |
| [28] | ［12］WEBER M. The Nature of Social Action ［M］∥RUNCIMAN W G, MATHEWS E. Max Weber: Selections in Translation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1978: 732. |
| [29] | ［18］BERNSTEIN T P, LYU X. Taxation without Representation: Peasants, The Central and the Local States in Reform China ［J］. China Quarterly, 2000, 163: 742763. |
| [30] | ［19］GUO X. Land Expropriation and Rural Conflicts in China ［J］. China Quarterly, 2001, 166: 422439. |
| [31] | ［20］LI L, O′BRIEN K J. Villagers and Popular Resistance in Contemporary China ［J］. Modern China, 1996, 22: 2861. |
| [32] | ［21］LI L. Political Trust in Rural China ［J］. Modern China, 2004, 30: 228258. |
| [33] | ［30］吕书鹏, 肖唐镖. 政府评价层级差异与差序政府信任――基于2011年全国调查数据的实证研究 ［J］. 北京行政学院学报, 2015(1): 2938. |
| [34] | ［32］谢秋山, 许源源. “央强地弱”政治信任结构与抗争性利益表达方式――基于城乡二元分割结构的定量分析 ［J］. 公共管理学报, 2012(4): 1220. |
