全部 标题 作者
关键词 摘要

OALib Journal期刊
ISSN: 2333-9721
费用:99美元

查看量下载量

相关文章

更多...

崂山冰臼之质疑

Keywords: 风化坑,冰臼,花岗岩,风化作用,崂山

Full-Text   Cite this paper   Add to My Lib

Abstract:

作者在2010年7月间考察了被认为是"中国东部沿海低海拔古冰川地貌保留完好"的崂山地区。考察结果显示崂山的地貌是正常的花岗岩地貌,并不是古冰川遗留的地形,崂山的冰臼不过是花岗岩地区常见的风化坑。本文将崂山风化坑与国外相关研究对比,列举了崂山冰臼不是冰臼的证据,对山顶冰臼形成理论提出了疑问,同时也回答了对风化坑形成的质疑。中国东部山顶冰臼是国内个别学者对国际上早已解决的科学问题产生的误解。

References

[1]  黄培华.五十年来中国东部第四纪冰川问题的研究及其争论.冰川冻土,1983, 5 (2):1~8
[2]  Huang Peihua.Resaerch and contention on the Quaternary glaciation problem of East China during last 50 years.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,1983, 5 (2):1~8
[3]  施雅风,崔之久,李吉均等.中国东部第四纪冰川与环境问题.北京: 科学出版社,1989.1~402
[4]  Shi Yafeng,Cui Zhijiu,Li Jijun et al.Quaternary Glacier and Environment in East China.Beijing: Science Press,1989.1~402
[5]  伍光和.冰川与冰川地貌研究.见: 吴传钧编.20世纪中国学术大典: 地理学.福州: 福建教育出版社,2002.63~67
[6]  Wu Guanghe.Study of glacier and glacial landforms.In: Wu Chuanjun ed.Chinese Academic Canon in the 20th Century: Geography.Fuzhou: Fujian Education Publishing House,2002.63~67
[7]  施雅风.韩同林的 "冰臼论" 是对花岗岩类岩石"负球状风化" 的误解.地质论评,2010, 56 (3):349~354
[8]  Shi Yafeng.Comments on the moul in argument provided by Mr.Han Tonglin,a misunderstanding of granite negative spheroidal weathering.Geological Review,2010, 56 (3):349~354
[9]  李吉均,舒 强,周尚哲等.中国第四纪冰川研究的回顾与展望.冰川冻土,2004, 26 (3):235~243
[10]  Li Jijun,Shu Qiang,Zhou Shangzhe et al.Review and prospects of Quaternary glaciation research in China. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,2004, 26 (3):235~246
[11]  吕洪波,任晓辉,杨 超.赤峰等地第四纪大陆冰川的地貌证据.地质论评,2006, 52 (3):379~385
[12]  Lu Hongbo,Ren Xiaohui,Yang Chao.Landform evidences of Quaternary continental glaciation in Chifeng and the vicinity areas,North of China.Geological Review,2006, 52 (3): 379~385
[13]  吕洪波,任晓辉,许 民等.壶穴差异风化或风蚀作用成因质疑.地质论评,2008, 54 (2):192~198
[14]  Lü Hongbo,Ren Xiaohui,Xu Min et al.An argument on the genesis of potholes formed by differential weathering or wind deflation.Geological Review,2008, 54 (2):192~198
[15]  韩同林.发现冰臼.北京: 华夏出版社,2004.1~4,78~82113~114
[16]  章雨旭."冰臼"成因争呜——以克什克腾旗青山岩臼群为例.地质论评,2005, 51 (6): 680712
[17]  Zhang Yuxu.An argument on the origin of potholes: A case of the Qingshan area,Hexigten Qi,Inner Mongolia.Geological Review,2005, 51 (6): 680712
[18]  周尚哲.锅穴一定是第四纪冰川的标志吗?第四纪研究,2006, 26 (1):117~125
[19]  Zhou Shangzhe.Are all potholes markers of Quaternary glaciation?Quaternary Sciences,2006, 26 (1):117~125
[20]  孙洪艳,田明中,武法东.克什克腾世界地质公园青山花岗岩臼的特征及成因研究.地质论评,2007, 53 (4):486~490
[21]  Sun Hongyan,Tian Mingzhong,Wu Fadong.Characteristics and origin of granite mortars in the Hexigten World Geopark.Geological Review,2007, 53 (4):486~490
[22]  朱 诚,崔之久,李中轩等.浙江缙云县大洋山石鼓尖花岗岩坑穴成因.地理学报,2008, 63 (7):735~743
[23]  Zhu Cheng,Cui Zhijiu,Li Zhongxuan et al.On genesis of the granite pits on top of the Dayangshan Mountain of Jinyun County,Zhejiang Province.Acta Geographica Sinica,2008, 63 (7):735~743
[24]  吕洪波,任晓辉,许 民等.再论山脊壶穴的冰川融水成因——兼与施雅风院士商榷.地质论评,2010, 56 (5):693~702
[25]  Lu Hongbo,Ren Xiaohui,Xu Min et al.On the meltwater origin of potholes found on granite ridges——A consultation with academician Shi Yafeng.Geological Review,2010, 56 (5):693~702
[26]  郭 良,相石宝,赵松龄.冰期之崂山.上海: 海科学技术出版社,2007.18111~112189~190
[27]  Guo Liang,Xiang Baoshi,Zhao Songling.Laoshan Mountain during Quaternary Ice Age.Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press,2007.18111~112189~190
[28]  李培英,徐兴永,赵松龄.海岸带黄土与古冰川遗迹.北京: 海洋出版社,2008.224~249291~302
[29]  Li Peiying,Xu Xingyong,Zhao Songling.The Loess and the Paleo-glaciation Remains in the Coastal Zone of China.Beijing: China Ocean Press,2008.224~249291~294
[30]  赵松龄.中国东部低海拔型古冰川遗迹.北京: 海洋出版社,2010.50~58197~244
[31]  Zhao Songling.The Paleo-glaciation Remains at Low Altitudes in East China.Beijing: China Ocean Press,2010.50~58197~244
[32]  Goodfellow B W. Relict non-glacial surfaces in formerly glaciated landscape.Earth Science Reviews,2007, 80 :47~73
[33]  Goudie A S, Migon P.Granite landforms of the Central Namib.Acta Universitatis Carolinae,2000, XXXV (Suppl.):17~38
[34]  André M F.Rates of postglacial rock weathering on glacially scoured outcrops(Abisko-Riksgrnsen Area,68°N).Geografiska Annaler, Series A,Physical Geography, 2002, 84 (3/4):139~150
[35]  Httestrand C, Stroeven A P.A relict landscape in the centre of Fennoscandian glaciation: Geomorphological evidence of minimal Quaternary glacial erosion.Geomorphology,2002, 44 :127~143
[36]  Briner J P, Miller G H,Davis P T et al.Last Glacial Maximum ice sheet dynamics in Arctic Canada in ferred from young erratics perched on ancient tors.Quaternary Science Reviews,2003, 22 :437~44
[37]  Hall A M, Glasser N F.Reconstructing the basal thermal regime of an ice stream in a landscape of selective linear erosion: Glen Avon,Cairngorm Mountains,Scotland.Boreas,2003, 32 :191~207
[38]  Hall A M, Phillips W M.Glacial modification of granite tors in the Cairngorms,Scotland.Journal of Quaternary Science,2006, 21 (8):811~830
[39]  Villar D D, Jennings C E.Multi-phase evolution of gnammas(weathering pits)in a Holocene deglacial granite landscape,Minnesota(USA).Earth Surface Processes and Landforms,2008, 33 :165~177
[40]  赵广涛,王德滋,曹钦臣等.I-A 型复合花岗岩体的热演化及其意义——以崂山花岗岩体为例.中国科学(D 辑),1998, 28 (4):296~302
[41]  Zhao Guangtao,Wang Dezi,Cao Qinchen et al.Thermal evolution and its significance of I-A type granitoid complex——The Laoshan granitoid as an example.Science in China(Series D),1998, 28 (4):296~302
[42]  Morgan A. Glacial potholes at Rockwood.The Grand Strategy Newsletter,2002, 7 (4):1~3
[43]  Alexander H S. Pothole erosion.Journal of Geology,1932, 40 (4):305~337
[44]  Mii H. Some ancient shore features.In: The Science Reports of the Tohoku University,Sendai,Japan,Second Series(Geology),Special Volume 51962. 361~371
[45]  Whipple K X, Hancock G S,Anderson R S.River incision into bedrock: Mechanics and relative efficacy of plucking,abrasion,and cavitation. Geological Society of America Bulletin,2000, 112 (3):490~503 2.0.CO;2 target="_blank">
[46]  Floyd J D. Pothole erosion of a dissected lake-shore platform in peat,Loch More,Halkirk,Caithness.Scotish Geographical Journal,2004, 120 (3):211~218
[47]  Post A. The recent surge of Walsh Glacier,Yukou and Alaska.Journal of Glaciology,1966, 6 (45):375~381
[48]  Collins S G. Survey of the rusty glacier area,Yukon Territory,Canada.Journal of Glaciology,1972, 11 (62):235~253
[49]  Dowdeswell J A, Hamilton G S,Hagen J O.The duration of the active phase on surge-type glaciers: Contrasts between Svalbard and other regions.Journal of Glaciology, 1991, 37 (127):388~400
[50]  Kleman J. Preservation of landforms under ice sheet and ice caps. Geomorphology,1994, 9 (1):19~32
[51]  Kleman J, Glasser N F.The subglacial thermal organisition(STO) of ice sheets.Quaternary Science Reviews,2007, 26 (5~6):585~597
[52]  Hambrey M, Alean J.Glaciers(2nd ed).New York: Cambridg University Press,2004.1~376
[53]  Goldich S S. A study in rock weathering.Journal of Geology,1938, 46 :17~58
[54]  Lorenc M W, Barco P M,Saavedra J.The evolution of potholes in granite bedrock,W Spain.Catena,1994, 22 :265~274
[55]  Zen E, Prestegaard K L.Possible hydraulic significance of two kinds of potholes: Examples from the paleo-Potomac River.Geology,1994, 22 :47~50
[56]  Dahl R. Plastically sculptured detail forms on rock surfaces in Northern Nordland,Norway.Geografiska Annaler,Series A,Physical Geography,1965, 47 (2):83~140
[57]  Sharpe D R, Shaw J.Erosion of bedrock by subglacial meltwater,Cantley,Quebec.Geological Society of America Bulletin, 1989, 101 :1011~1020 2.3.CO;2 target="_blank">
[58]  Fleeger G M, Braun D D,Inners J D.Plunge into the past or go with the flow: Multiple hypotheses for the origin of the Archbald Pothole,Lackawanna County,Pennsylvania.Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs,2002, 34 (1): 27
[59]  Harper J T, Humphrey N F,Pfeffer W T.Crevasse patterns and the strain-rate tensor: A high-resolution comparison.Journal of Glaciology,1998, 44 (146):68~76
[60]  Aniya M, Naruse R.Mapping structure and morphology of Soler Glacier,in Northern Patagonia,Chile,using near-vertical aerial photographs,taking with a non-metric 6×6cm-format camera.Annuals of Glaciology,1985, 8 :8~10
[61]  Campbell E M, Twidale C R.The various origins of minor granite landforms.Caderno Laboratorio Xeolóxico de Laxe (Coruna),1995, 20 :281~306
[62]  宋春青,张振春.地质学基础.北京: 人民出版社,1978.147
[63]  Song Chunqing,Zhang Zhenchun.Essential Geology.Beijing: Peoples Publishing House,1978.147
[64]  Han Tongli.Moulin Discovered.Beijing: Huaxia Press,2004.1~4,78~82113~114
[65]  韩同林,劳 雄,郭克毅.河北、内蒙古中低山区发现罕见的冰臼群.地质论评,1999, 15 (5):456~462
[66]  Han Tonglin,Lao Xiong,Guo Keyi.Rare moulin swarms discovered in the medium-low mountains areas in Hebei and Inner Mongolia.Geological Review,1999, 15 (5):456~462
[67]  崔之久,李洪江,南 凌等.内蒙、河北巨型壶穴与赤峰风道的发现.科学通报,1999, 44 (13):1429~1434
[68]  Cui Zhijiu,Li Hongjiang,Nan Ling et al.The discovery and environmental significance of Chifeng wind route and huge pots of Inner Mongolia and Hebei Province.Chinese Science Bulletin,1999, 44 (13):1429~1434
[69]  刘尚仁.关于冰臼形成与保存机理认识上的几个误区.热带地理,2000, 20 (2):156~161
[70]  Liu Shangren.Some mistaken views in cognition of the mechanism of formation and conservation of moulin.Tropical Geography,2000, 20 (2):156~161
[71]  李洪江,崔之久,赵 亮.内蒙、河北山区壶穴的成因探讨——兼论壶穴的成因分类.地理学报,2001, 56 (2):223~231
[72]  Li Hongjiang,Cui Zhijiu,Zhao Liang.Origin of pots in Inner Mongolia and Northern Hebei: Also about the classification of pots.Acta Geographica Sinica,2001, 56 (2):223~231
[73]  Goudie A S.Encyclopedia of Geomorphology.New York: Routledge,2004.1115~1116
[74]  Smith L L. Weather pits in granite of the southern Piedmont.Journal of Geomorphology,1941, 4 :117~127
[75]  Twidale C R. Weather pit(Gnamma). Australian Geographer,1965, 9 (5):318~319
[76]  Twidale C R, Romani J R V.Landforms and Geology of Granite Terrains.London: Taylor & Francis,2005.207~234
[77]  Migon P. Granite Landscapes of the World.New York: Oxford University Press,2006.132~160
[78]  Linton D L. The problem of tors.The Geographical Journal,1955, 121 (4): 470~481+487
[79]  Dahl R. Block fields,weathering pits and tor-like forms in the Narvik Mountains,Nordland,Norway.Geografiska Annaler,Series A,Physical Geography,1966, 48 (2):55~85
[80]  Johnsson G. Potholes: Glacial and non-glacial cavities.Geografiska Annaler, Series A,Physical Geography,1988, 70 (4):333~336
[81]  Villar D D. Early formation of gnammas(weathering pits)in a recently glaciated area of Torresdel Paine,Southern Patagonia(Chile).Geomorphology, 2006, 76 (1~2):137~147
[82]  Davis J. What are "potholes" and how are organisms able to live in them?Survey Note,Utah Geological Survey,2007, 39 (3): 11
[83]  Bayly I A E. Review of how indigenous people managed for water in desert regions of Australia.Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia,1999, 82 :17~25
[84]  Moore B. Speaking Our Language: The Story of Australian English.Melbourne: Oxford University Press,2008.9
[85]  Matthes F E. Geological History of the Yosemite Valley.U.S.Geological Survey,Professional Paper 1601930.1~137
[86]  Hubert N K. The geologic story of Yosemite National Park.U.S.Geological Survey Bulletin,15951987.1~64
[87]  Villar D D, Razola L,Carrasco R M et al.Weathering phases recorded by gnammas developed since last glaciation at Serra da Estrela,Portugal.Quaternary Research,2009, 72 (2):218~228
[88]  Hall A M, Phillips W M.Weathering pit as indicators of the relative age of granite surface in the Cairngorm Mountains,Scotland.Geografiska Annaler, Series A,Physical Geography, 2006, 88 (2):135~150
[89]  Campbell E M. Granite landforms.Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia,1997, 80 (3):101~112
[90]  Palmer J. Tor formation at the Bridestones in north-East Yorkshire and its significance in relation to problems of valley-side development and regional glaciation.Transactions and Papers(Institute of British Geographers),1956, 22 :55~71
[91]  Twidale C R. Granite landform evolution: Factors and implications.Geologische Rundschau,1986, 75 :769~779
[92]  Bourne J A, Twidale C R.Morphology and origin of three bornhardt inselbergs near Lake Johnston,Western Australia.Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia,2002, 85 (2):83~102
[93]  Riezebos H Th. Verweringskommen in Graniet.Sipaliwini-savanna,Zuid Suriname.Berichten Geografische Afdeling,1974, 8 : 25~33(Utrecht)
[94]  Roberts D. Occurrences of weathering pits from Sry,Northern Norway.Geografiska Annaler, Series A,Physical Geography,1968, 50 (1):60~63
[95]  Fahey B D. Weathering pit development in the Central Otago Mountains of Southern New Zealand. Arctic and Apline Research,1986, 18 (3):337~348
[96]  Watts S H. Weathering processes and products under arid arctic conditions: A study from Ellesmere.Geografiska Annaler, Series A,Physical Geography,1983, 65 (1/2):85~98
[97]  Villar D D, Arteaga,C,Giménez R G et al.Diurnal and seasonal water variations of temperature,pH,redox potential and conductivity in gnammas(weathering pits): Implications for chemical weathering.Catena,2008, 2 (1):37~48
[98]  Springer G S, Tools T,Wohl T T.Theoretical modeling of stream potholes based upon empirical observations from the Orange River,Republic of South Africa.Geomorphology,2006, 82 (1~2):160~176
[99]  王 为,黄 山,梁明珠.广东大峡谷河床壶穴形态的形成与发育.地理学报,2007, 62 (7):691~697
[100]  Wang Wei,Huang Shan,Liang Mingzhu.Formation and development of stream potholes in a gorge in Guangdong.Acta Geographica Sinica,2007, 62 (7):691~697
[101]  Higgins C G. Origin of potholes in glaciated rigons.Journal of Glaciology,1957, 3 (21):11~12
[102]  Gjessing J. Potholes in connection with plastic scouring forms.Geografiska Annaler, Series A,Physical Geography,1967, 49 (2/4):178~187
[103]  Kor P S G, Shaw J,Sharpe D R.Erosion of bedrock by subglacial meltwater,Georgian Bay,Ontario: A regional view.Journal of Earth Sciences,1991, 28 :623~642
[104]  Gilbert R. The Devil Lake pothole(Ontario): Evidence of subglacial fluvial processes.Geographic Physique et Quaternaire,2000, 54 (2):245~250
[105]  Morgan A V. Late Weichselian potholes near Wolverhampton,England. Journal of Glaciology,1970, 9 (55):125~133
[106]  Becher R S. Pot-hole and glacier mills.Journal of Glaciology,1951, 1 (9):488~490
[107]  Hollingworth S E. Pot-hole and glacier mills,some comments on Dr.R.Streiff-Beckers article.Journal of Glaciology,1951, 2 (11): 490
[108]  Faegri K. On the origin of pot-holes. Journal of Glaciology,1952, 2 (11):24~25

Full-Text

Contact Us

service@oalib.com

QQ:3279437679

WhatsApp +8615387084133