摘要 充分考虑石化装置的复杂工艺特点,建立了基于贝叶斯网络的危险与可操作性研究(HAZOP)、保护层分析(LOPA)、领结分析(Bow-Tie分析)于一体的复合型工艺风险评估模型.首先编制系统故障树,将其映射成对应贝叶斯网络,利用GeNIe软件实现贝叶斯双向推理进行故障预测和诊断,找出最容易导致事故的风险贝叶斯故障节点;然后运用HAZOP-LOPA集成分析研究该节点参数出现偏差的原因及后果,通过独立保护层失效概率评估风险等级;最后对剩余风险等级较高的事件进行Bow-Tie 分析,辨识出使保护层持续有效的关键活动,进而控制后果严重的工艺安全事故.以辽河石化公司的延迟焦化装置为例对该风险评估模型进行了现场应用.Abstract:Taking into full account the complex process of a petrochemical plant, a risk evaluation model based on Bayesian networks for composite techniques was built, which integrates HAZOP, LOPA and Bow-tie analysis. Firstly, the system fault tree was prepared, which was mapped into corresponding Bayesian networks, and the GeNIe software was utilized for fault prediction and diagnosis with the two-way reasoning of Bayesian networks and for locating the Bayesian risk fault node which most likely leads to accidents. Secondly, the causes and consequences of deviation occurring in the node parameters were studied by combining HAZOP and LOPA, and the risk level was confirmed through the failure probability of identified protection layers. Lastly, Bow-Tie analysis was applied to the remaining higher risk events for identifying the key activities to continuously sustain IPL effectively and then preventing the serious technique safety accidents from happening. Moreover, this risk evaluation model was put into use in the delayed coking device of Liaohe Petrochemical Company.
References
[1]
Ren J,Jenkinson I,Wang J.An offshore risk analysis method using fuzzy Bayesian network[J].Journal of Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering,2009,131(4):1-12.
[2]
Weber P,Medina O G,Simon C,et al.Overview on Bayesian networks applicatins for dependability,risk analysis and maintenance areas[J].Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence,2012,25(4):671-682.
[3]
Brooker P.Experts,Bayesian belief networks,rare events and aviation risk estimates[J].Safety Science,2011,49(8):1142-1155.
[4]
周建方,唐椿炎,许智勇.贝叶斯网络在大坝风险分析中的应用[J].水力发电学报,2010,29(1):192-196.(Zhou Jian-fang,Tang Chun-yan,Xu Zhi-yong.Application of Bayesian networks to dam risk analysis[J].Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering,2010,29(1):192-196.)
[5]
汪涛,廖彬超,马昕,等.基于贝叶斯网络的施工安全风险概率评估方法[J].土木工程学报,2013,43(增刊1):385-388.(Wang Tao,Liao Bin-chao,Ma Xin,et al.Using Bayesian network to develop a probability assessment approach or construction safety risk[J].China Civil Engineering Journal,2013,43(supl):385-388.)
[6]
Peal J.Fusion,propagation,and structuring in belief works[J].Artifical Intelligence,1986,29(3):241-288.
[7]
Hallowell M R,Gambatese J A.Construction safety risk mitigation[J].Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,2009,135(12):1316-1323.
[8]
许芝瑞,孙文勇,赵东风.HAZOP和LOPA两种安全评价方法的集成研究[J].安全与环境工程,2011,18(5):66-68.(Xu Zhi-rui,Sun Wen-yong,Zhao Dong-feng.Integrative research on two safety evaluation methods of HAZOP and LOPA[J].Safety and Environmental Engineering,2011,18(5):66-68.)
[9]
CCPS.Layers of protection analysis-simplified process risk assessment[M].New York:American Institute of Chemical Engineers,Center for Chemical Process Safety,2001.
[10]
李凤英,毕军,曲常胜,等.环境风险全过程评估与管理模式研究及应用[J].中国环境科学,2010,30(6):858-864.(Li Feng-ying,Bi Jun,Qu Chang-sheng,et al.Whole-precess environmental risk assessment and management and its application[J].China Environmental Science,2010,30(6):858-864.)(上接第736页)
[11]
刘丽荣,冯兵,李少游,等.工业地产与城市经济互动发展机理研究[J].商业时代,2009 (17):99-100.(Liu Li-rong Feng Bing,Li Shao-you,et al.The study of the development and the mechanism of industrial real estate and urban economic interaction[J].Commercial Times,2009 (17):99-100.)
[12]
Wheaton W C,Torto R G.An investment model of the demand and supply for industrial real estate[J].Real Estate Economics,1990,18(4):530-547.
[13]
Thomas J O.Environmental contamination and industrial real estate prices[J].Journal of Real Estate Research,2002,23(1):179-200.
[14]
王其藩.系统动力学[M].北京:清华大学出版社,1994.(Wang Qi-fan.System dynamics[M].Beijing:Tsinghua University Press,1994.)
[15]
陈悦华,廖造壮.基于系统动力学视角的武汉市商品住宅价格分析[J].科学技术与工程,2012,20(33):9132-9136.(Chen Yue-hua,Liu Zao-zhuang.Analysis of Wuhan commercial housing price based on system dynamics[J].Science and Technology and Engineering,2012,20 (33):9132-9136.)
[16]
Rose L A.Urban land supply:natural and contrived restrictions[J].Journal of Urban Economics,1989,25(3):325-345.
[17]
Williams J T.Real estate development as an option[J].The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,1991,4(2):191-208.