全部 标题 作者
关键词 摘要

OALib Journal期刊
ISSN: 2333-9721
费用:99美元

查看量下载量

相关文章

更多...

基于F1000与WoS的同行评议与文献计量相关性研究

Keywords: 同行评议,文献计量,F1000,WebofScience

Full-Text   Cite this paper   Add to My Lib

Abstract:

为比较同行评议与文献计量方法在科学评价中的有效性及相关性,选取F1000以及WebofScience数据库,采用SPSS16.0软件,将近2000篇论文的F1000因子与WebofScience数据库中指标进行相关性比较。结果显示,F1000因子与统计区间内的被引频次呈显著正相关,同时一些F1000因子很高的论文并没有高频被引,反之亦然。结论指出:从统计学的视角,文献计量指标与同行评议结果具有正向相关性,但是无论是同行评议还是文献计量,单独作为科学评价标准都会有失偏颇,以引文分析为代表的定量指标与同行评议方法的结合将是未来科学评价的主流。表4。参考文献14。

References

[1]  Oppenheim C,Out with the old and in with the new:The RAE,bibliometrics and new REF,JOURNAL OF LIBRARIANSHIP AND INFORMATION SCIENCE,2008(3).
[2]  Van Noorden R,A profusion of measures,NATURE,2010.
[3]  Norris M;Oppenheim C,Citation counts and the research assessment exercise V:Archaeology andthe 2001 research assessment exercise,Journal of Documentation,2003(6).
[4]  So C,Citation ranking versus expert judgment in evaluating communication scholars:Effects of re search specialty size and individual prominence,SCIENTOMETRICS,1998(3).
[5]  Norris M;Oppenheim C,Peer review and the h-in dex:Two studies,Journal of informetrics,2010(3).
[6]  Patterson M S;Harris S,The relationship between reviewers\' quality-scores and number of citations for papers published in the journal physics in med icine and biology from 2003-2005,Sciento metrics,2009(2).
[7]  Derrick G E,The association between four citation metrics and peer raukings of research influence of Australian researchers in six fields of public health,Plos One,2011(4).
[8]  DavidAW,Do \'Facultyof1000\' (F1000) rat ings of ecological publications serve as reasonable predictors of their future,Ideas in Ecology and Evolution,2010.
[9]  F1000[OL].http://f1000.com/,2011.
[10]  Webofknowledge[OL].http://isiknowledge.com/,2011.
[11]  迈克·塞沃尔;孙建军,链接分析:信息科学的研究方法,南京:东南大学出版社,2009.
[12]  薛薇,SPSS统计分析方法及应用,北京:电子工业出版社,2009.
[13]  Greene S,Peer review and the age of aquarius: It\'s time to reinvent the system that validates scientific discovery,The Scientist,2010(8).
[14]  Primo(z) Ju(z)ni (c),Scientometric indicators:Peer-re view,bibliometric methods and conflict of interests,SCIENTOMETRICS,2010(2).

Full-Text

Contact Us

service@oalib.com

QQ:3279437679

WhatsApp +8615387084133