Antarctic marine ecosystems have undergone significant changes as a result of human activities in the past and are now responding in varied and often complicated ways to climate change impacts. Recent years have seen the emergence of large-scale mechanistic explanations–or “paradigms of change”–that attempt to synthesize our understanding of past and current changes. In many cases, these paradigms are based on observations that are spatially and temporally patchy. The West Antarctic Peninsula (WAP), one of Earth’s most rapidly changing regions, has been an area of particular research focus. A recently proposed mechanistic explanation for observed changes in the WAP region relates changes in penguin populations to variability in krill biomass and regional warming. While this scheme is attractive for its simplicity and chronology, it may not account for complex spatio-temporal processes that drive ecosystem dynamics in the region. It might also be difficult to apply to other Antarctic regions that are experiencing some, though not all, of the changes documented for the WAP. We use qualitative network models of differing levels of complexity to test paradigms of change for the WAP ecosystem. Importantly, our approach captures the emergent effects of feedback processes in complex ecological networks and provides a means to identify and incorporate uncertain linkages between network elements. Our findings highlight key areas of uncertainty in the drivers of documented trends, and suggest that a greater level of model complexity is needed in devising explanations for ecosystem change in the Southern Ocean. We suggest that our network approach to evaluating a recent and widely cited paradigm of change for the Antarctic region could be broadly applied in hypothesis testing for other regions and research fields.
References
[1]
Vaughan D, Marshall G, Connolley W, Parkinson C, Mulvaney R, et al. (2003) Recent rapid regional climate warming on the Antarctic Peninsula. Climatic Change 60: 243–274.
[2]
Kravchenko VO, Evtushevsky OM, Grytsai AV, Milinevsky GP (2011) Decadal variability of winter temperatures in the Antarctic Peninsula region. Antarctic Science 23: 614–622.
[3]
Liu J, Curry JA, Martinson DG (2004) Interpretation of recent Antarctic sea ice variability. Geophysical Research Letters 31: L02205.
[4]
Smith RC, Stammerjohn SE (2001) Variations of surface air temperature and sea-ice extent in the western Antarctic Peninsula region. Annals of Glaciology 33: 493–500.
[5]
Hucke-Gaete R, Osman L, Moreno C, Torres D (2004) Examining natural population growth from near extinction: the case of the Antarctic fur seal at the South Shetlands, Antarctica. Polar Biology 27: 304–311.
[6]
Croxall JP, Callaghan T, Cervellati R, Walton DWH (1992) Southern Ocean environmental changes: effects on seabird, seal and whale populations. Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences 338: 319–328.
[7]
Ducklow HW, Clarke A, Dickhut R, Doney SC, Geisz H, et al.. (2012) The Marine Ecosystem of the West Antarctic Peninsula. In: Rogers A, Johnston N, Clarke A, Murphy E, editors. Antarctica: An Extreme Environment in a Changing World. London: Blackwell. 121–159.
[8]
Nicol S, Foster J, Kawaguchi S (2011) The fishery for Antarctic krill - recent developments. Fish and Fisheries 13(1): 30–40.
[9]
Marschoff ER, Barrera-Oro ER, Alescio NS, Ainley DG (2012) Slow recovery of previously depleted demersal fish at the South Shetland Islands, 1983–2010. Fisheries Research 125–126: 206–213.
[10]
Ainley DG, Blight LK (2009) Ecological repercussions of historical fish extraction from the Southern Ocean. Fish and Fisheries 10: 13–38.
[11]
Trivelpiece WZ, Hinke JT, Miller AK, Reiss CS, Trivelpiece SG, et al. (2011) Variability in krill biomass links harvesting and climate warming to penguin population changes in Antarctica. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108: 7625–7628.
[12]
Montes-Hugo M, Doney SC, Ducklow HW, Fraser W, Martinson D, et al. (2009) Recent changes in phytoplankton communities associated with rapid regional climate change along the western Antarctic Peninsula. Science 323: 1470–1473.
[13]
Moline MA, Claustre H, Frazer TK, Schofield O, Vernet M (2004) Alteration of the food web along the Antarctic Peninsula in response to a regional warming trend. Global Change Biology 10: 1973–1980.
[14]
Thorpe SE, Murphy EJ, Watkins JL (2007) Circumpolar connections between Antarctic krill (Euphausia superba Dana) populations: investigating the roles of ocean and sea ice transport. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers 54: 792–810.
[15]
Raymond B, McInnes J, Dambacher JM, Way S, Bergstrom DM (2011) Qualitative modelling of invasive species eradication on subantarctic Macquarie Island. Journal of Applied Ecology 48: 181–191.
[16]
Melbourne-Thomas J, Wotherspoon S, Raymond B, Constable A (2012) Comprehensive evaluation of model uncertainty in qualitative network analyses. Ecological Monographs 82: 505–519.
[17]
Dambacher J, Li H, Wolff J, Rossignol P (1999) Parsimonious interpretation of the impact of vegetation, food, and predation on snowshoe hare. Oikos 84: 530–532.
[18]
Dambacher J, Levins R, Rossignol P (2005) Life expectancy change in perturbed communities: Derivation and qualitative analysis. Mathematical Biosciences 197: 1–14.
[19]
Marzloff MP, Dambacher JM, Johnson CR, Little LR, Frusher SD (2011) Exploring alternative states in ecological systems with a qualitative analysis of community feedback. Ecological Modelling 222: 2651–2662.
[20]
Berlow EL, Neutel A-M, Cohen JE, De Ruiter PC, Ebenman B, et al. (2004) Interaction strengths in food webs: issues and opportunities. Journal of Animal Ecology 73: 585–598.
[21]
Levins R (1974) The qualitative analysis of partially specified systems. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 231: 123–138.
[22]
Bender EA, Case TJ, Gilpin ME (1984) Perturbation experiments in community ecology: theory and practice. Ecology 65: 1–13.
[23]
Puccia CJ, Levins R (1985) Qualitative Modeling of Complex Systems: An Introduction to Loop Analysis and Time Averaging. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
[24]
Atkinson A, Siegel V, Pakhomov E, Rothery P (2004) Long-term decline in krill stock and increase in salps within the Southern Ocean. Nature 432: 100–103.
[25]
Branch TA (2011) Humpback whale abundance south of 60°S from three complete circumpolar sets of surveys. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management (Special Issue) 3: 53–69.
[26]
Nicol S (2006) Krill, currents, and sea ice: Euphausia superba and its changing environment. BioScience 56: 111–120.
[27]
Ross R, Quetin L, Martinson D, Iannuzzi R, Stammerjohn S, et al. (2008) Palmer LTER: Patterns of distribution of five dominant zooplankton species in the epipelagic zone west of the Antarctic Peninsula, 1993–2004. Deep Sea Research Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography 55: 2086–2105.
[28]
Loeb V, Siegel V, Holm-Hansen O, Hewitt R (1997) Effects of sea-ice extent and krill or salp dominance on the Antarctic food web. Nature 387: 897–900.
[29]
Ducklow HW, Baker K, Martinson DG, Quetin LB, Ross RM, et al. (2007) Marine pelagic ecosystems: the West Antarctic Peninsula. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 362: 67–94.
[30]
Fraser WR, Trivelpiece WZ, Ainley DG, Trivelpiece SG (1992) Increases in Antarctic penguin populations: reduced competition with whales or a loss of sea ice due to environmental warming? Polar Biology 11: 525–531.
[31]
Lynch HJ, Naveen R, Trathan PN, Fagan WF (2012) Spatially integrated assessment reveals widespread changes in penguin populations on the Antarctic Peninsula. Ecology 93: 1367–1377.
[32]
McClintock J, Ducklow H, Fraser W (2008) Ecological responses to climate change on the Antarctic Peninsula. American Scientist 96: 302–310.
[33]
Schofield O, Ducklow HW, Martinson DG, Meredith MP, Moline MA, et al. (2010) How do polar marine ecosystems respond to rapid climate change? Science 328: 1520–1523.
[34]
Barbosa A, Benzal J, De León A, Moreno J (2012) Population decline of chinstrap penguins (Pygoscelis antarctica) on Deception Island, South Shetlands, Antarctica. Polar Biology 35: 1453–1457.
[35]
Naveen R, Lynch H, Forrest S, Mueller T, Polito M (2012) First direct, site-wide penguin survey at Deception Island, Antarctica, suggests significant declines in breeding chinstrap penguins. Polar Biology 35: 1879–1888.
[36]
Wiedenmann J, Cresswell KA, Mangel M (2009) Connecting recruitment of Antarctic krill and sea ice. Limnology and Oceanography 54: 799–811.
[37]
Atkinson A, Shreeve RS, Hirst AG, Rothery P, Tarling GA, et al. (2006) Natural growth rates in Antarctic krill (Euphausia superba): II. Predictive models based on food, temperature, body length, sex, and maturity stage. Limnology and Oceanography 51: 973–987.
[38]
Huang T, Sun L, Stark J, Wang Y, Cheng Z, et al. (2011) Relative changes in krill abundance inferred from Antarctic Fur Seal. PLoS ONE 6: e27331.
[39]
Reiss CS, Cossio AM, Loeb V, Demer DA (2008) Variations in the biomass of Antarctic krill (Euphausia superba) around the South Shetland Islands, 1996–2006. ICES Journal of Marine Science 65: 497–508.
[40]
Fulton EA, Smith ADM, Johnson CR (2003) Effect of complexity on marine ecosystem models. Marine Ecology Progress Series 253: 1–16.
[41]
Bernard KS, Steinberg DK, Schofield OME (2012) Summertime grazing impact of the dominant macrozooplankton off the Western Antarctic Peninsula. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers 62: 111–122.
[42]
Trathan PN, Ratcliffe N, Masden EA (2012) Ecological drivers of change at South Georgia: the krill surplus, or climate variability. Ecography 35: 983–993.
[43]
Daly KL, Zimmerman JJ (2004) Comparisons of morphology and neritic distributions of Euphausia crystallorophias and Euphausia superba furcilia during autumn and winter west of the Antarctic Peninsula. Polar Biology 28: 72–81.
[44]
Murphy EJ, Watkins JL, Trathan PN, Reid K, Meredith MP, et al. (2007) Spatial and temporal operation of the Scotia Sea ecosystem: a review of large-scale links in a krill centred food web. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 362: 113–148.
[45]
Chapman E, Hofmann E, Patterson D, Ribic C, Fraser W (2011) Marine and terrestrial factors affecting Adélie- penguin Pygoscelis adeliae chick growth and recruitment off the western Antarctic Peninsula. Marine Ecology Progress Series 436: 273–289.
[46]
Emslie S, Patterson W (2007) Abrupt recent shift in δ13 C and δ15 N values in Adelie penguin eggshell in Antarctica. PNAS 104: 11666–11669.
[47]
Hinke J, Polito M, Reiss C, Trivelpiece S, Trivelpiece W (2012) Flexible reproductive timing can buffer reproductive success of Pygoscelis spp. penguins in the Antarctic Peninsula region. Marine Ecology Progress Series 454: 91–104.
[48]
Lynch H, Fagan W, Naveen R, Trivelpiece S, Trivelpiece W (2012) Differential advancement of breeding phenology in response to climate may alter staggered breeding among sympatric pygoscelid penguins. Marine Ecology Progress Series 454: 135–145.
