Amidst ongoing declines in honey bee health, the contributory role of the newer systemic insecticides continues to be intensely debated. Scores of toxicological field experiments, which bee scientists and regulators in the United States have looked to for definitive causal evidence, indicate a lack of support. This paper analyzes the methodological norms that shape the design and interpretation of field toxicological studies. I argue that contemporary field studies of honey bees and pesticides are underpinned by a “control-oriented” approach, which precludes a serious investigation of the indirect and multifactorial ways in which pesticides could drive declines in honey bee health. I trace the historical rise to prominence of this approach in honey bee toxicology to the development of entomology as a science of insecticide development in the United States. Drawing on “complexity-oriented” knowledge practices in ecology, epidemiology, beekeeping and sociology, I suggest an alternative socio-ecological systems approach, which would entail in situ studies that are less concerned with isolating individual factors and more attentive to the interactive and place-based mix of factors affecting honey bee health.
References
[1]
Biesmeijer, J.C.; Roberts, S.P.M.; Reemer, M.; Oholemuller, R.; Edwards, M.; Peeters, T.; Schaffers, A.P.; Potts, S.G.; Kleukers, R.; Thomas, C.D.; et al. Parallel Declines in Pollinators and Insect-Pollinated Plants in Britain and the Netherlands. Science 2006, 313, 351–354, doi:10.1126/science.1127863.
[2]
National Research Council (N.R.C.). Status of Pollinators in North America; The National Academies Press: Washington, DC, USA, 2007.
[3]
Pettis, J.S.; Delaplane, K.S. Coordinated Responses to Honey Bee Decline in the USA. Apidologie 2010, 41, 256–263, doi:10.1051/apido/2010013.
[4]
Stokstad, E. The Case of the Empty Hives. Science 2007, 316, 970–973, doi:10.1126/science.316.5827.970.
[5]
VanEngelsdorp, D.; Evans, J.D.; Saegerman, C.; Mullin, C.; Haubruge, E.; Nguyen, B.K.; Frazier, M.; Frazier, J.; Cox-Foster, D.; Chen, Y.; et al. Colony Collapse Disorder: A Descriptive Study. PLoS One 2009, 4, e6481, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0006481.
[6]
U.S.D.A. Colony Collapse Disorder Progress Report; Agricultural Research Service: Washington, DC, USA, 2010.
[7]
VanEngelsdorp, D.; Hayes, J., Jr.; Underwood, R.M.; Caron, D.; Pettis, J. A Survey of Managed Honey Bee Colony Losses In the USA, Fall 2009 to Winter 2010. J. Apic. Res. 2011, 50, 1–10, doi:10.3896/IBRA.1.50.1.01.
[8]
Cox-Foster, D.L.; Conl an, S.; Holmes, E.C.; Palacios, G.; Evans, J.D.; Moran, N.A.; Quan, P.-L.; Briese, T.; Hornig, M.; Geiser, D.M.; et al. A Metagenomic Survey of Microbes in Honey Bee Colony Collapse Disorder. Science 2007, 318, 283–287, doi:10.1126/science.1146498.
[9]
Johnson, R.M.; Evan, J.D.; Robinson, G.E.; Berenbaum, M.R. Changes in Transcript Abundance Relating to Colony Collapse Disorder in Honey Bees (Apis mellifera). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 200 2009, 106, 14790–14795, doi:10.1073/pnas.0906970106.
[10]
Bromenshenk, J.J.; Henderson, C.B.; Wick, C.H.; Stanford, M.F.; Zulich, A.W.; Jabbour, R.E.; Deshpande, S.V.; McCubbin, P.E.; Seccomb, R.A.; Welch, P.M.; et al. Iridovirus and Microsporidian Linked to Honey Bee Colony Decline. PLoS One 2010, 5, e13181, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0013181.
[11]
See the Letter to the EPA from Commercial Beekeepers Belonging to the National Honey Bee Advisory Board (17 March 2009; Docket # EPA-HQ-OPP-2008-0844-0010). 0010. Available online: http://www.regulations.gov/#!documentDetail;D=EPA-HQ-OPP-2008-0844-0102/ (accessec on 28 February 2013).
[12]
Bonmatin, J.M.; Moineau, I.; Charvet, R.; Colin, M.E.; Fleche, C.; Bengsch, E.R. Behaviour of imidicloprid in fields. Toxicity for honey bees. In Environmental Chemistry: Green Chemistry of Pollutants in Ecosystems; Lichtfouse, E., Schwarzbauer, J., Robert, D., Eds.; Springer-Verlag: Heidelberg, Germany, 2005; pp. 483–494.
[13]
Maus, C.; Curé, G.; Schmuck, R. Safety of Imidacloprid Seed Dressings to Honey Bees: A Comprehensive Review and Compilation of the Current State of Knowledge. Bull. Insectol. 2003, 56, 51–57.
[14]
Cutler, C.G.; Scott-Dupree, C.D. Exposure to Clothianidin Seed-Treated Canola Has No Long-Term Impact on Honey Bees. J. Econ. Entomol. 2007, 100, 765–772, doi:10.1603/0022-0493(2007)100[765:ETCSCH]2.0.CO;2.
[15]
Dively, G.P.; Embrey, M.; Pettis, J.S. Assessment of Sublethal Effects of Imidacloprid on Honey Bee and Colony Health: Final Report Submitted to the North American Pollinator Protection Campaign. Available online: http://entomology.umd.edu/files/entm/documents/mhwg/NAPPC_final_report_of_2008_study-Dively.pdf (accessed on 11 November 2011).
[16]
Henry, M.; Beguin, M.; Requier, F.; Rollin, O.; Odoux, J.-F.; Aupinel, P.; Aptel, J.; Tchamitchian, S.; Decourtye, A. A Common Pesticide Decreases Foraging Success and Survival in Honey Bees. Science 2012, 336, 348–350, doi:10.1126/science.1215039.
[17]
Blacquière, T.; Smagghe, G.; van Gestel, C.A.M.; Mommaerts, V. Neonicotinoids in Bees: A Review on Concentrations, Side-effects and Risk Assessment. Ecotoxicology 2012, 21, 973–992, doi:10.1007/s10646-012-0863-x.
[18]
Creswell, J.E.; Desneux, N.; vanEngelsdorp, D. Dietary Traces of Neonicotinoid Pesticides as a Cause of Population Declines in Honey Bees: An Evaluation by Hill’s Epidemiological Criteria. Pest Manag. Sci. 2012, 68, 819–827, doi:10.1002/ps.3290.
EPA Response to Sierra Club’s Request to Suspend Nicotinyl Insecticides (10 October 2008; Docket # EPA-HQ-OPP-2008-0844-0120). Available online: http://www.regulations.gov/ #!documentDetail;D=EPA-HQ-OPP-2008-0844-0120/ (accessec on 28 February 2013).
[21]
Desneux, N.; Decourtye, A.; Delpuech, J.-M. The Sublethal Effects of Pesticides on Beneficial Arthropods. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 2007, 52, 81–106, doi:10.1146/annurev.ento.52.110405.091440.
[22]
Iwasa, T.; Motoyama, N.; Ambrose, J.T.; Roe, M. Mechanism for the Differential Toxicity Neonicotinoid Insecticides in the Honey Bee, Apis mellifera. Crop Prot. 2004, 23, 371–378, doi:10.1016/j.cropro.2003.08.018.
[23]
Alaux, C.; Brunet, J.-L.; Dussaubat, C.; Mondet, F.; Tchamitchan, S.; Cousin, M.; Brillard, J.; Baldy, A.; Belzunces, L.P.; Le Conte, Y. Interactions Between Nosema Microspores and a Neonicotinoid Weaken Honeybees (Apis mellifera). Environ. Microbiol. 2009, 12, 774–782.
[24]
EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency) Pollinator Protection in the EPA’s Office of Pesticide Programs. Pesticide Program Dialogue Committee Meeting Transcript. Available online: http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/ppdc/2008/oct2008/transcript.pdf (accessed on 26 October 2009).
[25]
Johnson, R.M.; Ellis, M.D.; Mullin, C.A.; Frazier, M. Pesticides and Honey Bee Toxicity-USA. Apidologie 2010, 41, 312–331, doi:10.1051/apido/2010018.
[26]
Bayer CropScience. Honeybee Colony Losses and Honeybee Health Issues—Recent Scientific Literature and Findings on Causative Factors. Available online: http://www.bayercropscience.com/bcsweb/cropprotection.nsf/id/EN_Recent_Scientific_Literature_and_Findings_on_Causative_Factors_2010/ (accessed on 30 November 2010).
[27]
Pettis, J.S.; vanEngelsdorp, D.; Johnson, J.; Dively, G. Pesticide Exposure in Honey Bees Results in Increased Levels of the Gut Pathogen Nosema. Naturwissenschaften 2012, 99, 153–158, doi:10.1007/s00114-011-0881-1.
[28]
EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency) Technical Support Document for the Response to the Emergency Citizen Petition Seeking Suspension of Registration for Clothianidin Based on Claims of Imminent Hazard to the Environment (17 July 2012; Docket # EPA-HQ-OPP-2012-0334). Available online: http://www.regulations.gov/#!documentDetail;D=EPA-HQ-OPP-2012-0334-0012/ (accessec on 28 February 2013).
[29]
Oliver, R. Neonicotinoids: Trying to Make Sense of the Science. Am. Bee J. 2012, 152, 805–812.
[30]
B？schen, S.; Kastenhofer, K.; Rust, I.; Soentgen, J.; Wehling, P. The Political Dynamics of Scientific Non-Knowledge. Sci. Technol. Hum. Values 2010, 35, 783–811, doi:10.1177/0162243909357911.
[31]
Kirk, S.A.; Kutchins, H. The Selling of the DSM: The Rhetoric of Science in Psychiatry; Aldine de Gruyter: New York, NY, USA, 1992.
[32]
Spivak, M. The Status of the European Honey Bee in the U.S. In Managing Alternative Pollinators: A Handbook for Growers, Beekeepers and Conservationists; Mader, E., Spivak, M., Evans, E., Eds.; Natural Resource, Agriculture and Engineering Service: Ithaca, NY, USA, 2010; pp. 15–24.
[33]
Holmstrup, M.; Bindesbol, A.-M.; Oostingh, G.J.; Duschl, A.; Scheil, V.; K？hler, H.-R.; Loureiro, S.; Soares, A.M.V.M.; Fereira, A.L.G.; Kienle, C. Interactions Between Effects of Environmental Chemicals and Natural Stressors: A Review. Sci. Total Environ. 2010, 408, 3746–3762, doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2009.10.067.
[34]
Mullin, C.A.; Frazer, M.; Frazier, J.L.; Ashcroft, S.; Simonds, R.; vanEngelsdorp, D.; Pettis, J.S. High Levels of Miticides and Agrochemicals in North American Apiaries: Implications for Honey Bee Health. PLoS One 2010, 5, e9754.
[35]
Frazier, M.; Mullin, C.A.; Frazier, J.L.; Ashcroft, S. What Have Pesticides Got To Do With It? Am. Bee J. 2008, 148, 521–523.
[36]
Suryanarayanan, S.; Kleinman, D.L. B(e)ecoming Experts: The Controversy Over Insecticides in the Honey Bee Colony Collapse Disorder. Soc. Stud. Sci. 2013, doi:10.1177/0306312712466186.
[37]
Palladino, P. Entomology, Ecology and Agriculture: The Making of Scientific Careers in North America 1885–1985; Harwood Academic Publishers: Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1996.
[38]
Sleigh, C. Six Legs Better: A Cultural History of Myrmecology; The Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA, 2007.
[39]
Lowe, V.H.; Parrott, P.J. San José Scale Investigations; Bulletin No. 228; New York Agricultural Experimental Station: Geneva, NY, USA, 1902.
[40]
Anderson, L.D.; Atkins, E.L., Jr. Effects of Pesticides on Bees: Laboratory and Field Tests Study the Effects of Agricultural Pesticides on Highly Important Pollinators of State’s Crops. Calif. Agr. 1958, 12, 3–4.
[41]
Anderson, L.D.; Atkins, E.L., Jr. Pesticide Usage in Relation to Beekeeping. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 1968, 13, 213–238, doi:10.1146/annurev.en.13.010168.001241.
[42]
Weaver, N. Toxicity of Organic Insecticides: Contact Spray and Field Tests. J. Econ. Entomol. 1951, 44, 393–397.
[43]
Kleinman, D.L. Science and Technology in Society: From Biotechnology to the Internet; Blackwell Publishing: Malden, MA, USA, 2005.
[44]
Kleinman, D.L.; Suryanarayanan, S. Dying Bees and the Social Production of Ignorance. Sci. Technol. Hum. Values 2012, doi:10.1177/0162243912442575.
[45]
Likens, G.E. Lake Ecosystem Ecology; Elsevier: San Diego, CA, USA, 2010.
[46]
Rothman, K. Epidemiology: An Introduction, 2nd ed.; Oxford University Press: New York, NY, USA, 2012.
[47]
Kosek, J. Ecologies of Empire: On the New Uses of the Honey Bee. Cult. Anthropol. 2010, 25, 650–678, doi:10.1111/j.1548-1360.2010.01073.x.
[48]
Silverman, C. Pollinator Health Problems as Contested Illnesses: A Social Study of Knowledge Production. In Presented at the Center for Pollinator Research Symposium; Pennsylvania State University: State College, PA, USA, 2012.
[49]
VanEngelsdorp, D.; Tarpy, D.R.; Baylis, K.; Spivak, M.; Caron, D.M.; Connell, J.; Delaplane, K.S.; Donohue, S.; Esaias, W.; Gross, B.; et al. The Bee Informed Partnership: Using Beekeeper’s Real-World Experience to Solve Beekeepers’ Real-World Problems. Am. Entomol. 2012, 58, 116–118.
[50]
Moritz, R.A.; Southwick, E.E. Bees as Superorganisms: An Evolutionary Reality; Springer-Verlag: Berlin, Germany, 1992.
[51]
Glaser, M.; Krause, G.; Ratter, B.M.W.; Welp, M. Human-Nature Interactions in the Anthropocene: Potentials of Social-Ecological Analysis; Routledge: New York, NY, USA, 2012.
[52]
Aspelin, A.L. Pesticide Usage in the United States: Trends During the 20th Century; Technical Bulletin 105; Center for Integrated Pest Management: Raleigh, NC, USA, 2003.
[53]
USDA (U.S. Department of Agriculture). The 20th Century Transformation of U.S. Agriculture and Farm Policy. Available online: http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/259572/eib3_1_.pdf (accessed on 15 August 2012).
[54]
Cameron, S.A.; Lozier, J.D.; Strange, J.P.; Koch, J.B.; Cordes, N.; Solter, L.F.; Griswold, T.L. Patterns of Widespread Decline in North American Bumble Bees. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2011, 108, 662–667.
[55]
Liu, J.; Dietz, T.; Carpenter, S.R.; Alberti, M.; Folke, C.; Moran, E.; Pell, A.N.; Deadman, P.; Kratz, T.; Lubchenco, J.; et al. Complexity of Coupled Human and Natural Systems. Science 2007, 317, 1513–1516, doi:10.1126/science.1144004.
[56]
Gibbons, M.; Limoges, C.; Nowotny, H.; Scwartzman, S.; Scott, P.; Trow, M. The New Production of Knowledge: The Dynamics of Science and Research in Contemporary Societies; Sage: London, UK, 1994.
