The enigma that is the nucleus pulposus cell: the search goes on

A recent issue of Arthritis Research and Therapy contains a report by Gilson and colleagues describing their investigation of the differential cell surface marker expression found in samples of bovine intervertebral disc (IVD) and articular chondrocytes [1]. This report raises interesting questions about the identity of the residents within the nucleus pulposus (NP) and has broad implications with respect to regenerative medicine and tissue engineering of the IVD.A recent search of PubMed using the search term 'tissue engineering and intervertebral disc' returned 263 hits, with the oldest publication dating to 1989. Although investigators have clearly been interested in developing a biological treatment for degenerative disc disease for over 30 years, we must be in the early days since we have yet to characterize the ubiquitous NP cell or to really understand the composition of the NP cellular milieu.The flexible model of cell and tissue classification whereby expression patterns reflect a functional approach rather than strict germ layer derivation suggests that, with respect to the identity of NP cells, there may be more than meets the eye [2].The notochord derives from all three germ layers as it originates in a blended fashion from primitive ectoderm, sharing mesodermal and endodermal attributes as it develops as an outgrowth from Hensen's node between the ectoderm and endoderm [3]. This co-joined origin is particularly poignant in human and other mammals, as distinct from lower animals, because in higher mammals the developing notochord provides a pathway for migration of ectoderm to endoderm [3]. The presence of vimentin in NP cells suggests that motility may play a role in the development of the NP cellular composition; perhaps including cells that migrate inwards from the vertebral endplates [4]. As Gilson and colleagues have reported, however, the cells occupying the NP may change their appearance over time, masking their original phenotype but perhaps reta