The Park 51 controversy swept like wildfire through the media in late August of 2010, fueled by Islamophobes who oppose all advance of Islam in America. Yet the controversy also resonated with many who were clearly not caught up in the fear of Islam. This article attempts to understand the broader concern that the Park 51 project would somehow violate the Ground Zero site, and, thus, as a sign of "respect" should be moved to a different location, an argument that was invariably articulated in “spatial language” as groups debated the physical and spatial presence of the buildings in question, their relative proximity, and even the shadows they cast. This article focuses on three sets of spatial meanings that undergirded these arguments: the site as sacred ground created through trauma, rebuilding as retaliation for the attack, and the assertion of American civil religion. The article locates these meanings within a broader civic discussion of liberty and concludes that the spatialization of the controversy opened up discursive space for repressive, anti-democratic views to sway even those who believe in religious liberty, thus evidencing a deep ambivalence regarding the legitimate civic membership of Muslim Americans.
References
[1]
J.C. Hernandez. “Archbishop Offers Mediation for Islamic Center.” New York Times, 18 August 2010. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/19/nyregion/19dolan.html?ref=javierchernandez (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[2]
J.C. Hernandez. “Giuliani Says Mosque Near Ground Zero is Offensive.” New York Times, 18 August 2010. http://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/08/19/giuliani-says-mosque-near-ground-zero-is-offensive/?ref=javierchernandez (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[3]
P. Vitello. “For High Holy Days, Rabbis Weigh their Words on Proposed Islamic Center.” New York Times, 8 September 2010. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/09/nyregion/09jews.html?ref=paulvitello (accessed on 2 April 2011).Foxman's position was based in part upon an earlier incident in which a Carmelite convent was established in a building near the former concentration camp at Auschwitz and several dozen crosses, including one well over twenty-feet high, were erected near the camp to memorialize Polish Christian victims of the Nazis. In that case, lengthy negotiations between Catholic and Jewish leaders resulted in the removal of the crosses and the relocation of the convent to a more distant site.
[4]
A.H. Foxman. “ADL and the Ground Zero Mosque.” http://www.adl.org/ADL_Opinions/Civil_Rights/JerusalemReport_Sept2010.htm (accessed on 29 June 2011).
[5]
The “compromise” offered by Governor Patterson was also supported by many people who opposed Islam entirely, including Sarah Palin. While an important viewpoint in the debate, this ideological position is less puzzling than that of those, including Muslims, who adopted the compromise position as a good-faith effort to work out the disagreement.
[6]
S. Parker. “Sarah Palin Questions Obama's Support for Ground Zero Mosque.” Politics Daily, 14 August 2010. http://www.politicsdaily.com/2010/08/14/sarah-palin-questions-obamas-support-for-ground-zero-mosque/ (accessed on 17 April 2011).
[7]
R. Sherrill. “American Sacred Space and the Contest of History.” In American Sacred Space. Edited by D. Chidester, and E.T. Linenthal. Bloomington, IN, USA: Indiana University Press, 1995, pp. 313–322.
[8]
M. Eliade. The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion. San Diego, CA, USA: Harcourt Brace & Company, 1987, pp. 20–36.
[9]
J.Z. Smith. To Take Place: Toward Theory in Ritual. Chicago, IL, USA: The University of Chicago Press, 1987, pp. 16–23.
[10]
E. Durkheim. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2001, pp. 221–28.
[11]
D. Chidester, and E.T. Linenthal. “Introduction.” In American Sacred Space. Edited by D. Chidester, and E.T. Linenthal. Bloomington, IN, USA: Indiana University Press, 1995.
[12]
D.B. Caruso. “Population Near Ground Zero has Doubled Since 2000.” Statesman.com, 1 April 2011. http://www.statesman.com/news/nation/population-near-ground-zero-has-doubled-since-2000-1368392.html (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[13]
National Public Radio; Talk of the Nation. “Gettysburg, Ground Zero: Secular Sacred Spaces.” http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=129555581 (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[14]
“Interview: Father Brian Jordan.” Religion & Ethics Newsweekly, 2 September 2002. http://www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/week601/p-jordan.html (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[15]
R. Dreher. “Holy Symbols of Hope Amid the Rubble.” NYPost.com, 23 September 2001. http://webarchive.loc.gov/lcwa0001/20010926073216/ http://www.nypost.com/commentary/4613.htm (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[16]
J. Erwin, and A. Erwin. “The Cross and the Towers.” ,？2006. Film.
[17]
Country musician Alan Jackson's song, “Where were you when the world stopped turning,” which focuses on the confusion of personal responses to the September 11 attacks and places that confusion in religious and patriotic contexts, also emphasizes this non-militant character.
[18]
P. Goldberger. Up from Zero: Politics, Architecture, and the Rebuilding of New York. New York, NY, USA: Random House, 2005, Volume 172.
[19]
Of course, financial motivations were central to the desire to rebuild quickly. Silverstein was, for instance, was well aware that in order to obtain the highest insurance payout he would need to base his claim on rebuilding the site (Goldberger, 41).
[20]
J. Wolschke-Bulmahn, ed. “On the martial response to perceived threats to national sites, see Linenthal. E.T. Sacred Ground: Martial Landscape in American Culture.” In Places of Commemoration: Search for Identity and Landscape Design. Washington, DC, USA: Dumbarton Oaks, 2001.
[21]
E.T. Linenthal. Sacred Ground: Americans and Their Battlefields. Urbana, IL, USA: University of Illinois Press, 1993.
[22]
P. Nobel. Sixteen Acres: Architecture and the Outrageous Struggle for the Future of Ground Zero. New York, NY, USA: Metropolitan Books, 2005, pp. 96–117.
[23]
M. Halbwachs. The Collective Memory. New York, NY, USA: Harper & Row, 1980, p. 140.
[24]
Philip Nobel offers a compelling analysis of the contradictory aspects of the rebuilding process [22].
[25]
R.N. Bellah. “Civil Religion in America.” Daedalus, 1967, 96. Available online: http://www.robertbellah.com/articles_5.htm (accessed on 10 April 2010).
[26]
CBS News. “A Time for Patriotism.” CBE News, 2001. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2001/11/20/holidays/main318684.shtml (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[27]
E.T. Linenthal. Sacred Ground: Americans and Their Battlefields. Urbana, IL, USA: University of Illinois Press, 1993, p. 163.
[28]
D. Chidester. Patterns of Power: Religion and Politics in American Culture. Englewood Cliffs, NJ, USA: Prentice Hall, 1988, pp. 301–306.
[29]
P. Vitello. “In Fierce Opposition to a Muslim Center, Echoes of an Old Fight.” New York Times, 7 October 2010. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/08/nyregion/08zero.html?_r=1&ref=paul_vitello (accessed on 21 October 2010).
[30]
“Hawaii Kotohira Jinsha-Hawaii Dazaifu Tenmangua Shrine.” http://www.e-shrine.org/history.html (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[31]
R. Hines. “Ground Zero Project Moves Forward.” Tricycle, 3 August 2010. http://www.tricycle.com/blog/?p=2136 (accessed on 26 October 2010).
[32]
M.F. Greene. “On The Templesee.” In The Temple Bombing. Reading, MA, USA: Addison-Wesley, 1996.
[33]
“On violence against mosques, see Vandals Damage Islamic Center in Chicago.” The Islamic Voice, June 1999. http://www.islamicvoice.com/june.99/news.htm (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[34]
S. Musaji. “Mosques in the U.S. That Have Experienced Violent or Racist Incidents.” American Muslim Perspective, 30 November 2006. http://www.ghazali.net/archives2006/html/mosques_in_us_that.html (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[35]
J.C. Alexander. “Classification: On the Polarizing Discourse of Civil Society.” In Cultivating Differences: Symbolic Boundaries and the Making of Inequality. Edited by M. Lamont, and M. Fournier. Chicago, IL, USA: University of Chicago Press, 1992.
[36]
H. Lefebvre. “On the spatialized character of social processessee.” In The Production of Space. Oxford, UK: Blackwell, 1991.
[37]
E.W. Soja. “On the spatialized character of social processessee.” In Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-Imagined Places. Cambridge, MA, USA: Blackwell, 1996, pp. 45–47.
[38]
PBS Newshour. “9 Years After 9/11, Has Religious Tolerance Changed in America?” http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/terrorism/july-dec10/911_09-10.html (accessed on 2 April 2011).
[39]
see Rex Sorgatz's photograph of the site as it appeared during the controversy, at Beale S. Photo: World Trade Center Site on September 11, 2010, Laughing Squid: http://laughingsquid.com/photo-world-trade-center-site-on-september-11-2010/ (accessed on 12 July 2011)
