Background To examine explanations for the higher rates of male mortality in two Scottish cohorts compared with a cohort in south-east England for which similar data were collected. Methodology/Principal Findings We compared three cohort studies which recruited participants in the late 1960s and early 1970s. A total of 13,884 men aged 45–64 years at recruitment in the Whitehall occupational cohort (south-east England), 3,956 men in the Collaborative occupational cohort and 6,813 men in the Renfrew & Paisley population-based study (both central Scotland) were included in analyses of all-cause and cause-specific mortality. All-cause mortality was 25% (age-adjusted hazard ratio 1.25, 95% confidence interval (CI)1.21 to 1.30) and 41% (hazard ratio 1.41 (95% CI 1.36 to 1.45) higher in the Collaborative and Renfrew & Paisley cohorts respectively compared to the Whitehall cohort. The higher mortality rates were substantially attenuated by social class (to 8% and 17% higher respectively), and were effectively eliminated upon the further addition of the other baseline risk factors, such as smoking habit, lung function and pre-existing self-reported morbidity. Despite this, coronary heart disease mortality remained 11% and 16% higher, stroke mortality 45% and 37% higher, mortality from accidents and suicide 51% and 70% higher, and alcohol-related mortality 46% and 73% higher in the Collaborative and Renfrew & Paisley cohorts respectively compared with the Whitehall cohort in the fully adjusted model. Conclusions/Significance The higher all-cause, respiratory, and lung cancer male mortality in the Scottish cohorts was almost entirely explained by social class differences and higher prevalence of known risk factors, but reasons for the excess mortality from stroke, alcohol-related causes, accidents and suicide remained unknown.
References
[1]
McCartney G, Walsh D, Whyte B, Collins C (2011) Has Scotland always been the ‘sick man’ of Europe? European Journal of Public Health. pp. 1–5. (doi:10.1093/eurpub/ckr1136).
[2]
Whyte B (2007) Scottish mortality in a European context 1950-2000: an analysis of comparative mortality trends. Edinburgh: Scottish Public Health Observatory.
[3]
Leon D, Morton S, Cannegieter S, McKee M (2003) Understanding the health of Scotland’s population in an International context: a review of current approaches, knowledge and recommendations for new research directions. London: London School of Hygience and Tropical Medicine & Public Health Institute for Scotland.
[4]
Shaw M, Davey-Smith G, Dorling D (2005) Health inequalities and New Labour: how the promises compare with real progress. BMJ 330: 1016.
[5]
Walsh D, Taulbut M, Hanlon P (2010) The aftershock of deindustrialization–trends in mortality in Scotland and other parts of post-industrial Europe. European Journal of Public Health 20: 58–64.
[6]
McLoone P (2003) Increasing mortality among adults in Scotland 1981 to 1999. European Journal of Public Health 13: 230e234.
[7]
Carstairs V, Morris R (1989) Deprivation: explaining differences in mortality between Scotland and England and Wales. BMJ 299: 886–889.
[8]
Hanlon P, Lawder R, Buchanan D, Redpath A, Walsh D, et al. (2005) Why is mortality higher in Scotland than in England & Wales? Decreasing influence of socioeconomic deprivation between 1981 and 2001 supports the existence of a ‘Scottish effect’. Journal of Public Health 27: 199–204.
[9]
Walsh D, Bendel N, Jones R, Hanlon P (2010) It’s not ‘just deprivation’: why do equally deprived UK cities experience different health outcomes? Public Health 124: 487–495.
[10]
Mitchell R, Fowkes G, Blane D, Bartley M (2005) High rates of ischaemic heart disease in Scotland are not explained by conventional risk factors. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 59: 565–567.
[11]
Norman P, Boyle P, Exeter D, Feng Z, Popham F (2011) Rising premature mortality in the Uk’s persistently deprived areas: only a Scottish phenomenon? Social Science and Medicine 73: 1–10.
[12]
Reid D, Brett G, Hamilton P, Jarrett R, Keen H, et al. (1974) Cardiorespiratory disease and diabetes among middle-aged male civil servants. Lancet i.
[13]
Davey-Smith G, Hart C, Hole D, MacKinnon P, Gillis C, et al. (1998) Education and occupational social class: which is the more important indicator of mortality risk? Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 52: 153–160.
[14]
Hawthorne V, Watt G, Hart C, Hole D, Davey-Smith G, et al. (1995) Cardiorespiratory disease in men and women in urban Scotland: baseline characteristics of the Renfrew/Paisley (Midspan) population study. Scottish Medical Journal 40: 102–107.
[15]
Hart C, MacKinnon P, Watt G, Upton M, McConnachie A, et al. (2005) The Midspan Studies. International Journal of Epidemiology. International Journal of Epidemiology 34: 28–34.
[16]
(1966) General Register Office. Classification of Occupations 1966. London: HMSO. pp. 1–148.
[17]
Rose G, Blackburn H, Gillum R, Prineas R (1982) Cardiovascular survey methods. Geneva: World Health Organisation.
[18]
Council MR (1965) Definition and classification of chronic bronchitis for epidemiological purposes. Lancet I: 775–779.
[19]
Rose G, Blackburn H (1968) Cardiovascular survey methods. Geneva: World Health Organisation.
[20]
Kivim？ki M, Ferrie J, Batty G, Davey-Smith G, Elovainio M, et al. (2008) Optimal form of operationalizing BMI in relation to all-cause and cause specific mortality. Obesity 16: 1926–1932.
[21]
Smith G, Shipley M, Hole D, Hart C, Watt G, et al. (1995) Explaining male mortality differentials between the west of Scotland and the south of England. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 49: 541.
[22]
Menvielle G (2010) Occupational exposures contribute to educational inequalities in lung cancer incidence among men: Evidence from the EPIC prospective cohort study. International Journal of Cancer 126: 1928–1935.
[23]
Smith G, Hart C, Watt G, Hole D, Hawthorne V (1998) Individual social class, area-based deprivation, cardiovascular disease risk factors, and mortality: the Renfrew and Paisley Study. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 52: 399–405.
[24]
Rose G, Shipley M (1986) Plasma cholesterol concentration and death from coronary heart disease: 10 year results of the Whitehall study. BMJ 293: 306–307.
[25]
Morris R, Whincup P, Lampe F, Walker M, Wannamethee S, et al. (2001) Geographic variation in incidence of coronary heart disease in Britain: the contribution of established risk factors. Heart 86: 277–283.
[26]
Leyland A, Dundas R, McLoone P, Boddy F (2007) Cause-specific inequalities in mortality in Scotland: two decades of change. A population-based study. BMC Public Health. 7 p.
[27]
Dorling D, Rigby J, Wheeler B, Ballas D, Thomas B, et al. (2007) Poverty, wealth and place in Britain, 1968–2005. Bristol: Policy Press and Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
[28]
McCartney G, Collins C, Walsh D, Batty G (2011) Explaining Scotland’s mortality: towards a synthesis. Glasgow: Glasgow Centre for Population Health.
[29]
McCarttney G, Collins C, Walsh D, Batty G (2012) Explaining Scotland’s mortality: towards a synthesis. Public Health. (in press).
[30]
Smith G, Dorling D, Gordon D, Shaw M (1999) The widening health gap: what are the solutions? Critical Public Health 9: 151–170.
[31]
Dorling D (2010) Injustice: why social inequality persists. Bristol: Policy Press.
