The Montreux Document aims to regulate the use of PMSCs by States during armed conflict, with the aim of promoting respect for international humanitarian law and human rights law by PMSCs. Private maritime security companies that contract with shipping companies to engage in anti-piracy acts for merchant ships may operate in situations where they may shoot pirates indiscriminately or torture those who have been subdued. Whether the Montreux Document adjusts and applies to this, scholars have formed two contrasting views, starting from the fact that it applies only during armed conflict. This paper, based on the interpretive perspective, provides a systematic reading of the purpose, object, scope and content of the Montreux Document, and concludes that although not all provisions of the Montreux Document can be applied to private maritime security companies, the provisions of the Montreux Document on good practice can help and promote the business activities of private maritime security companies. The Montreux Document’s good practice provisions can help and facilitate the business activities of private maritime security companies.
Cite this paper
Ren, X. (2022). Analysis on the Application of Montreux Document to Private Maritime Security Companies from the Perspective of Interpretation Theory. Open Access Library Journal, 9, e8532. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1108532.
Swiss Federal Department of Foreign Affairs (2022) Participating States of the Montreux Document.
https://www.eda.admin.ch/eda/en/home/foreign-policy/international-law/international-humanitarian-law/private-military-security-companies/participating-states.html
Burkov, Y. and Wärff, F. (2012) The Fight against Maritime Piracy: Possibilities of Application of Private Security Organizations off the Coast of Somalia under National and International Regulation. 38-39.
https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:541787/FULLTEXT02.pdf
Parsons, D.M. (2010) Protecting the Booty: Creating a Regulatory Framework to Govern Increased Use of Private Security Companies in the Fight against Pirates. Tulane Maritime Law Journal, 35, 174.
DeMaio, A. (2015) Upping the Stakes to Win the War against Somali Piracy: Justifications for a New Strategy Based on International Humanitarian Law. George Mason Law Review, 22, 391, 424.
Coito, J.C. (2013) Pirates vs. Private Security: Commercial Shipping, the Montreux Document, and the Battle for the Gulf of Aden. California Law Review, 101, 209-212.
Vijayan, S. (2014) The Use of Armed Forces on Merchant Vessels without Strict Rules for the Use of Force. Journal of Maritime Law and Commerce, 45, 15-34.
Klinkenberg, I.K. (2013) Pirates versus Private Security Companies: A Road to Safety or Insecurity at Sea. Master Thesis, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Oslo.