Expropriation is the transfer of assets and ownership rights from private to public property, after a fair and previously determined compensation. The Constitution of the Republic of Moldova, the Civil Code and the Land Code stipulates a “fair and previously determined compensation” in case of ownership transfer. The existing legislative acts in the Republic of Moldova explain the expropriation procedure, but do not cover the estimation process of the compensations and damages caused by the expropriation. In the present study, the authors examine the existing legislative and methodological framework used in the process of estimation process of the compensations amount. The notions of “normative price” and “market price” as “fair compensation” are examined. The challenges and legislative gaps that exist at each stage of the compensation assessment process in case of expropriation of real estate are analyzed. It has been found that the national practice of estimating the damage in case of expropriation for public utility does not ensure the compliance with the principles of equivalence and fails to achieve equitable treatment of the interests of both the private owners and the public administration bodies. It has been observed that the state is damaged by the lack of certainty regarding the valuation date for the assessment of compensation, the owners by not considering some categories of losses, and both parties by the lack of methodological provisions on assessing compensation for expropriation. Based on the research carried out, the authors propose their own methodology for assessing the compensation amount in case of expropriation for public utility in the conditions of the Republic of Moldova.
Cite this paper
Albu, S. and Lesan, A. (2021). Estimation of the Compensation Amount in the Process of Expropriation of Real Estate in the Republic of Moldova. Open Access Library Journal, 8, e7309. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1107309.
Albu, S. and Lesan, A. (2017) The Specifics of Land Valuation in Case of Expropriation for Public Utility Purpose of National and Local Level in the Republic of Moldova. Матерiали ХХХ Мiжнародноï науково-практичноï iнтернет-конференцiï Тенденцiï та перспективи розвитку науки i освiти в умовах глобалiзацiï: Зб. наук. праць. Переяслав-Хмельницький, 74-76. http://confscientific.webnode.com.ua
Law No. 1308 of 25.07.1997 on Normative Price and Procedure of Sale and Purchase of Land. In: Official Gazette No. 147-149 of 06.12.2001.
http://lex.justice.md/viewdoc.php?action=view&view=doc&id=313289&lang=1
Law No. 989-XV of 18.04.2002 on Evaluation Activity. In: Official Gazette No. 102 of 16.07.2002. https://www.legis.md/cautare/getResults?doc_id=108062&lang=ro
Government Decision No. 958 of 04.08.2003 on the Approval of the Provisional Regulation on the Valuation of Real Estate. In: Official Gazette No. 177 of 15.08.2003. http://lex.justice.md/viewdoc.php?action=view&view=doc&id=305725&lang=1
Law No. 105 of 09.06.2017 on the Declaration of Public Utility for Works of National Interest in the Construction of the Ungheni-Chisinau Natural Gas Pipeline. In: Official Gazette No. 216-228 from 09.06.2017.
Government Decision No. 1237 of 19.12.2018 on the Expropriation for Public Utility of Real Estate (Land) and the Right of Use Over Real Estate (Land) Located on the Site of Works of National Interest in the Construction of the Ungheni-Chisinau Natural Gas Pipeline. In: Official Gazette No. 13-21 from 18.01.2019.
Lesan, A. (2020) Factors Identification Influencing Compensation Size in Case of Property Expropriation for Public Utility. Journal of Social Sciences, 3, 65-69.
Lesan, A. (2019) Expropriation of Real Estate in the Framework of Consistency with International Norms. Экономика и предпринимательство No. 6 (107), 558-562.