All Title Author
Keywords Abstract

Modelling Financially Optimal Afforestation and Forest Management Scenarios Using a Bio-Economic Model

DOI: 10.4236/ojf.2016.61003, PP. 19-38

Keywords: Forestry, Bio-Economic Modelling, Afforestation, Optimisation

Full-Text   Cite this paper   Add to My Lib


The expansion of non-industrial private forests (NIPF) in Ireland is unique in the European context in which the almost doubling of forest cover within the last thirty years has taken place largely on farmland. This is not surprising as Ireland has some of the highest growth rates for conifers in Europe and also has a large proportion of land which is marginal for agriculture but highly productive under forests. However, in recent years, afforestation in Ireland as in many European countries has fallen well short of policy targets. As the farm afforestation decision essentially involves an inter-temporal land use change, farmers need comprehensive information on forest market returns under different environmental conditions and forest management regimes. This paper describes the systematic development of a cohort forest bio-economic model which examines financially optimal afforestation and management choices. Simulating a range of productivity and harvesting scenarios for Sitka spruce, we find that different objectives result in different outcomes. We see substantial differences between the biologically optimal rotation, the reduced rotation in common usage and the financially optimal rotation which maximises net present value and find that the results are particularly sensitive to the choice of management and methodological assumptions. Specifically, we find that better site productivity and thin versus no-thin options result in shorter rotations across all optimisations, reinforcing the usefulness of this type of financial modelling approach. This information is critical for future policy design to further incentivise afforestation of agricultural land.


[1]  Anon (1977). Operational Directive (1/77) “Rotation Lengths and Thinning Regimes for Conifers” Forest and Wildlife Service, Merrion St., Dublin.
[2]  Assmuth, A., & Tahvonen, O. (2015). Continuous Cover Forestry vs. Clearcuts with Optimal Carbon Storage. Paper presented at BioEcon 2015, Cambridge, England, September 2015.
[3]  Bateman, I. J., Lovett, A. A., & Brainard, J. S. (2006). Applied Environmental Economics—A GIS Approach to Cost Benefit Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[4]  Bettinger, P., Boston, K., Siry, J. P., & Grebner, D. L. (2010). Forest Management and Planning. Cambridge, MA: Academic Press.
[5]  Boardman, A. E., Greenberg, D. H., Vining, A. R., & Weimer, D. L. (2011) Cost-Benefit Analysis: Concepts and Practice (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
[6]  Broad, L. R., & Lynch, T. (2006). Growth Models for Sitka Spruce. Irish Forestry, 63, 80-95.
[7]  Clinch, J. P. (1999). Economics of Irish Forestry: Evaluating the Returns to Economy and Society. Dublin: COFORD.
[8]  CSO (2014). Central Statistics Office.
[9]  DAFM (2015). Afforestation Grant and Premium Schemes.
[10]  Diaz-Balteiro, L., & Romero, C. (2003). Forest Management Optimisation Models When Carbon Captured Is Considered: A Goal Programming Approach. Forest Ecology and Management, 174, 447-457.
[11]  Edwards, P. N., & Christie, J. M. (1981). Yield Models for Forest Management, Forestry Commission Booklet 48. London: HMSO.
[12]  European Commission (2013). Ministerial Conferences.
[13]  European Council (2014). The 2014 European Council Agreement on Climate and Energy Targets for 2030 (EUCO 169/14).
[14]  Eurostat (2013). Agriculture, Forestry and Fishery Statistics 2013.
[15]  Farrelly, N., NiDhubhain, A., & Niewenhuis, M. (2011). Modelling and Mapping the Potential Productivity of Sitka Spruce from Site Factors in Ireland. Irish Forestry, 68, 23-40.
[16]  Flichman, G., & Allen, T. (2013). Bio-Economic Modelling: State-of-the-Art and Key Priorities.
[17]  Graves, A. R., Burgess, P. J., Palma, J. H., Herzog, F., Moreno, G., Bertomeu, M., & Van den Briel, J. P. (2007). Development and Application of Bio-Economic Modelling to Compare Silvoarable, Arable, and Forestry Systems in Three European Countries. Ecological Engineering, 29, 434-449.
[18]  Halbritter, A., & Deegen, P. (2015). A Combined Economic Analysis of Optimal Planting Density, Thinning and Rotation for an Even-Aged Forest Stand. Forest Policy and Economics, 51, 38-46.
[19]  Hamilton, G. J. (1975). Forest Mensuration Handbook. F.C. Booklet No. 39, London: HMSO.
[20]  Herbohn, J., Emtage, N., Harrison, S., & Thompson, D. (2009). The Australian Farm Forestry Financial Model. Australian Forestry, 72, 184-194.
[21]  Hiley, W. E. (1954). Woodland Management. London: Faber & Faber.
[22]  Hiley, W. E. (1956). Economics of Plantations. London: Faber & Faber.
[23]  Husch, B., Miller, C. I., & Beers, T. W. (1982). Forest Mensuration (402 p). New York: Wiley.
[24]  ITGA (2014). Irish Timber Growers Yearbook. Dublin: Irish Timber Growers Association.
[25]  Janssen, S., Louhichi, K., Kanellopoulos, A., Zander, P., Flichman, G., Hengsdijk, H., Meuter, E., Andersen, E., Belhouchette, H., Blanco, M., Borkowski, N., Heckelei, T., Hecker, M., Li, H., Oude Lansink, A., Stokstad, G., Thorne, P., van Keulen, H., & van Ittersum, M. K. (2010). A Generic Bio-Economic Farm Model for Environmental and Economic Assessment of Agricultural Systems. Environmental Management, 46, 862-877.
[26]  Jordan, P. (1992). Volume Assortment Tables for Sitka Spruce (Piceasitchensis (Bong. Carr)) in Ireland. M. Agr.Sc (For) Thesis, National University of Ireland, 133 p.
[27]  Kerr, G., & Haufe, J. (2011). Thinning Practice—A Silvicultural Guide. Edinburgh: Forestry Commission.
[28]  Kubicki, A., Denby, C., Haagensen, A., & Stevens, M. (1991). Farmula User Manual. South Perth: Western Australia Department of Agriculture.
[29]  Lecocq, F., Caurla, S., Delacote, P., Barkaoui, A., & Sauquet, A. (2011). Paying for Forest Carbon or Stimulating Fuelwood Demand? Insights from the French Forest Sector Model. Journal of Forest Economics, 17, 157-168.
[30]  Loane, B. (1994). The FARMTREE Model: Computing Financial Returns from Agroforestry. Faces of Farm Forestry. Proceedings of Australian Forest Growers Conference, Launceston, 2-4 May 1994, 275-285.
[31]  Matthews, R. W., & Mackie, E. D. (2006). Forest Mensuration: A Handbook for Practitioners. Edinburgh: Forestry Commission.
[32]  McKenney, D. W., Yemshanov, D., Fox, G., & Ramlal, E. (2006). Using Bioeconomic Models to Assess Research Priorities: A Case Study on Afforestation as a Carbon Sequestration Tool. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 36, 886-900.
[33]  Middlemiss, P., & Knowles, L. (1996). AEM Agroforestry Estate Model, User Guide for v. 4.0. Rotorua: New Zealand Forest Research Institute.
[34]  Namaalwa, J., Sankhayan, P. L., & Hofstad, O. (2007). A Dynamic Bio-Economic Model for Analyzing Deforestation and Degradation: An Application to Woodlands in Uganda. Forest Policy and Economics, 9, 479-495.
[35]  Phillips, H. (1998). Rotation Length, Thinning Intensity and Felling Decision for Blue Areas. Report Commissioned by Coillte Forests, Coillte, Dublin.
[36]  Phillips, H. (2004). Review of Rotation Lengths for Conifer Crops. Report Commissioned by Coillte Forest, Coillte, Dublin.
[37]  Phillips, H. (2011). All Ireland Roundwood Production Forecast 2011-2028. Dublin: COFORD.
[38]  Phillips, H., Little, D., McDonald, T., & Phelan, J. (2013). A Guide to the Valuation of Commercial Forest Plantations. Dublin: COFORD.
[39]  Phillips, H., Redmond, J., Mac Siurtain, M., & Nemesova, A. (2009). Roundwood Production from Private Sector Forests 2009-2028. A Geospatial Forecast. Dublin: COFORD.
[40]  Pihlainen, S., Tahvonen, O., & Makela, A. (2015). Economics of Boreal Scots Pine Stands under Changing Climate. BIOECON 2015 Conference, Cambridge, 13-15 September 2015.
[41]  Ryan, M., McCormack, M., O’Donoghue, C., & Upton, V. (2014). The Role of Subsidy Payments in the Uptake of Forestry by the Typical Cattle Farmer in Ireland from 1984 to 2012. Irish Forestry, 71, 92-112.
[42]  Ryan, M., O’Donoghue, C., Upton, V., Phillips, H., & Farrelly, N. (2013). Modelling Inter-Temporal Differential Returns to Agricultural and Forestry Land Use Using the Forest Investment and Valuation Estimator (FIVE). 87th Annual Conference of the Agricultural Economics Society, University of Warwick, Coventry, 8-10 April 2013.
[43]  Sankhayan, P. L., Gurung, N., Sitaula, B. K., & Hofstad, O. (2003). Bio-Economic Modeling of Land Use and Forest Degradation at Watershed Level in Nepal. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 94, 105-116.
[44]  Smith, D. M. (1986). The Practice of Silviculture (8th ed.). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
[45]  Standiford, R. E., & Howitt, R. B. (1992). Solving Empirical Bioeconomic Models: A Rangeland Management Application. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 74, 421-434.
[46]  Tahvonen, O., Pihlainen, S., & Niinimaki, S. (2013). On the Economics of Optimal Timber Production in Boreal Scots Pine Stands. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 43, 719-730.
[47]  Teagasc (2015). First Thinning of Conifers.
[48]  Tikkanen, O. P., Matero, J., Monkkonen, M., Juutinen, A., & Kouki, J. (2012). To Thin or Not to Thin: Bio-Economic Analysis of Two Alternative Practices to Increase Amount of Coarse Woody Debris in Managed Forests. European Journal of Forest Research, 131, 1411-1422.
[49]  Upadhyay, T. P., Solberg, B., & Sankhayan, P. L. (2006). Use of Models to Analyse Land-Use Changes, Forest/Soil Degradation and Carbon Sequestration with Special Reference to Himalayan Region: A Review and Analysis. Forest Policy and Economics, 9, 349-371.
[50]  van Kooten, G., Binkley, C., & Delcourt, G. (1995). Effect of Carbon Taxes and Subsidies on Optimal Forest Rotation Age and Supply of Carbon Services. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 77, 365-374.
[51]  Vanclay, J. K. (1998). FLORES: For Exploring Land Use Options in Forested Landscapes.
[52]  Varian, H. R. (2010). Intermediate Microeconomics—A Modern Approach. New York and London: W.W. Norton & Co.
[53]  Verburg, P. H., Schot, P. P., Dijst, M. J., & Veldkamp, A. (2004). Land Use Change Modelling: Current Practice and Research Priorities. GeoJournal, 61, 309-324.
[54]  West, G. G., Moore, J. R., Shula, R. G., Harrington, J. J., Snook, J., Gordon, J. A., & Riordan, M. P. (2012). Forest Management DSS Development in New Zealand. Conference Paper.


comments powered by Disqus