|
论医务人员保密义务及其犯罪界限
|
Abstract:
医务人员的保密义务可追溯至上千年前,在医疗事业趋向精细化的今天,尤其是组织性、分工性医疗形态的出现为该义务提出了新的挑战。医生保密义务背后的法益存在个人利益与社会利益的争论,但目前更多的学者认为二者兼有;在保密义务的主体问题上,应当将其进行扩大解释,不能仅限于医生这一范围内;保密义务并非是不可违反的,在特定情况下可以为其找到正当化根据;在刑法规制上,不能只注重定量而忽视定性,应当对医疗信息进行分类保护,采取不同的入罪定量要求。
The confidentiality obligation of medical personnel can be traced back thousands of years. In to-day’s increasingly refined medical industry, especially with the emergence of organizational and division of labor medical forms, this obligation has posed new challenges. There is a debate be-tween personal and social interests regarding the legal benefits behind the obligation of confidentiality for doctors, but currently more scholars believe that both are present; in terms of the subject matter of confidentiality obligations, it should be expanded and not limited to the scope of doctors; the obligation of confidentiality is not inviolable and can be justified in specific circumstances; in terms of criminal law regulation, we cannot only focus on quantitative analysis while neglecting qualitative analysis. We should classify and protect medical information and adopt different quantitative requirements for criminalization.
[1] | 陈俊榕. 论刑法上医师保密义务[J]. 台湾海洋法学报, 2016(24): 51-71. |
[2] | [德]埃里克?希尔根多夫. 医疗刑法导论[M]. 王芳凯, 译. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2021. |
[3] | 杨莹. 论我国患者医疗信息刑法保护的完善[J]. 福建警察学院学报, 2020, 34(5): 90-97. |
[4] | [日]甲斐克则, 刘建利. 医疗信息保护与利用的刑事法问题——以精神鉴定医泄露秘密案最高裁决定为契机[J]. 法学论坛, 2014, 29(5): 30-39. |
[5] | 石佳友. 个人信息保护的私法维度——兼论《民法典》与《个人信息保护法》的关系[J]. 比较法研究, 2021(5): 14-32. |
[6] | 刘建利. 医务人员违反守密义务的犯罪界限[J]. 中国刑事法杂志, 2017(4): 94-109. |
[7] | 杨慧艳. 对一起侵犯患者隐私权引发的医疗诉讼案的分析[J]. 中国医药指南, 2009, 7(2): 140-141+127. |
[8] | 魏伶娟. 论医师保密义务之原则与例外——一个摆荡于保障医疗人权与维护公共利益间的难题[J]. 东海大学法学研究, 2016(50): 49-85. |
[9] | 储陈城, 胡子昕. 大数据时代个人医疗信息利用的入罪界限——对《刑法》第二百五十三条之一的再思考[J]. 四川师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2021, 48(1): 82-90. |
[10] | 赵秉志. 公民个人信息刑法保护问题研究[J]. 华东政法大学学报, 2014(1): 117-127. |
[11] | 王旭. 数据法定继承规则的情境化构建[J]. 时代法学, 2022, 20(1): 53-61. |