%0 Journal Article
%T 网游用户协议无效的法律适用模式——以数据财产权为中心
Legal Application Models for the Invalidity of Online Game User Agreements—Centered on Data Property Rights
%A 杨炎
%J Dispute Settlement
%P 8-16
%@ 2379-3104
%D 2025
%I Hans Publishing
%R 10.12677/ds.2025.114121
%X 通过梳理现有网络用户协议和司法裁判，可以发现存在网游用户协议条款效力判断标准不一、呈现未体系化的“霰弹式”裁判问题。该裁判模式集中体现了网络游戏用户协议治理规范供给不足、学理针对性弱的现实困境。基于对数据财产权的法律定性、法律行为论、网络格式合同法理基础的规范脉络分析，可以归纳出无效事由的“游戏轴线”与“合同轴线”，通过类型化裁判路径，构成对于无效网游用户协议法律适用模式的限制，有助于优化网游用户协议效力的司法裁判路径，促进网络空间法治建设。
By analyzing existing online user agreements and judicial rulings, it is evident that there are inconsistencies in the criteria for determining the validity of online game user agreement clauses, leading to fragmented and uncoordinated “shotgun-style” adjudication practices. This adjudication model highlights the current challenges of insufficient regulatory provisions and weak theoretical foundations in the governance of online game user agreements. Based on a normative analysis of the legal characterization of data property rights, legal act theory, and the doctrinal foundations of online standard contracts, this study identifies two axes for invalidating agreements—the “game axis” and the “contract axis”. Through a typological adjudicatory approach, these axes establish constraints on legal application models for invalidating online game user agreements. This framework contributes to optimizing judicial pathways for determining the validity of online game user agreements, thereby advancing the rule of law in cyberspace governance
%K 网游用户协议，
%K 网络游戏，
%K 数据财产权，
%K 合同效力
Online Game User Agreements
%K Online Games
%K Data Property Rights
%K Contract Validity
%U http://www.hanspub.org/journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=110316