%0 Journal Article %T Trauma, place, and transformation %A Altaf Engineer %A Esther M. Sternberg %A Hester Oberman %J Archive for the Psychology of Religion %@ 1573-6121 %D 2019 %R 10.1177/0084672418824067 %X This commentary comprises three different responses to Counted and Zock¡¯s article: ¡°Place Spirituality: An Attachment Perspective.¡± The first response is from Esther Sternberg, MD, who gives a psychophysiological and neuroscience critique. The second is from Altaf Engineer, PhD, from the perspective of architecture and environmental psychology, and the last response is from Hester Oberman, PhD, who gives a psychology of religion rebuttal %K Attachment object %K conditional place preference %K emergence %K environmental psychology %K human geography %K place attachment %K place spirituality %K surrogate attachment %K transformation %K trauma %U https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0084672418824067