%0 Journal Article
%T Plant Fitness Assessment for Wild Relatives of Insect Resistant Bt-Crops
%A D. K. Letourneau
%A J. A. Hagen
%J Journal of Botany
%D 2012
%I Hindawi Publishing Corporation
%R 10.1155/2012/389247
%X When field tests of transgenic plants are precluded by practical containment concerns, manipulative experiments can detect potential consequences of crop-wild gene flow. Using topical sprays of bacterial Bacillus thuringiensislarvicide (Bt) and larval additions, we measured fitness effects of reduced herbivory on Brassica rapa (wild mustard) and Raphanus sativus (wild radish). These species represent different life histories among the potential recipients of Bt transgenes from Bt cole crops in the US and Asia, for which rare spontaneous crosses are expected under high exposure. Protected wild radish and wild mustard seedlings had approximately half the herbivore damage of exposed plants and 55% lower seedling mortality, resulting in 27% greater reproductive success, 14-day longer life-spans, and 118% more seeds, on average. Seed addition experiments in microcosms and in situ indicated that wild radish was more likely to spread than wild mustard in coastal grasslands. 1. Introduction Commercialized transgenic, insect resistant (IR) crops currently grown in the United States have virtually no wild relatives near production sites, thus ensuring that novel crop traits are unlikely to move into local wild gene pools. However, an assessment of the consequences of gene flow will be necessary in future deregulation decisions because most of the major and minor crops in the world either exist in the wild themselves or hybridize with wild relatives somewhere in their range [1¨C5]. Wild relatives of transformed plants that obtain IR traits through gene flow and introgression may be released from the pressure exerted by susceptible herbivores [6¨C14]. However, scant knowledge about the ecological factors that regulate the abundance, competitive ability, or geographic range of weeds limits our ability to predict whether novel plant defenses are likely to increase the weediness of wild crop relatives [14] or even whether herbivory has a negative or positive effect on plant growth and fitness [15¨C20]. Surprisingly, few tests have been conducted on the effects of herbivory on the spread of invasive plants [21, 22] or to quantify the effects of herbivory on plant vital rates [23]. Identifying and quantifying environmental risks associated with gene flow from transgenic crops is subject to methodological tradeoffs because of containment restrictions, especially for plant fitness effects, which require pollen production. Field tests with pollen-producing transgenic plants must be contained physically in cages or greenhouses or established at sites where wild relatives do
%U http://www.hindawi.com/journals/jb/2012/389247/