%0 Journal Article
%T Be careful with triage in emergency departments: interobserver agreement on 1,578 patients in France
%A Anne-Claire Durand
%A St¨¦phanie Gentile
%A Patrick Gerbeaux
%A Marc Alazia
%A Pierre Kiegel
%A Stephane Luigi
%A Eric Lindenmeyer
%A Philippe Olivier
%A Marie-Annick Hidoux
%A Roland Sambuc
%J BMC Emergency Medicine
%D 2011
%I BioMed Central
%R 10.1186/1471-227x-11-19
%X We conducted a multicentric cross-sectional study to compare agreement between nurses and physicians on categorization of ED visits into urgent or nonurgent. Subgroups stratified by criteria characterizing the ED visit were analyzed in relation to the outcome of the visit.Of 1,928 ED patients, 350 were excluded because data were lacking. The overall nurse-physician agreement on categorization was moderate (kappa = 0.43). The levels of agreement within all subgroups were variable and low. The highest agreement concerned three subgroups of complaints: cranial injury (kappa = 0.61), gynaecological (kappa = 0.66) and toxicology complaints (kappa = 1.00). The lowest agreement concerned two subgroups: urinary-nephrology (kappa = 0.09) and hospitalization (kappa = 0.20). When categorization of ED visits into urgent or nonurgent cases was compared to hospitalization, ED physicians had higher sensitivity and specificity than nurses (respectively 94.9% versus 89.5%, and 43.1% versus 30.9%).The lack of physician-nurse agreement and the inability to predict hospitalization have important implications for patient safety. When urgency screening is used to determine treatment priority, disagreement might not matter because all patients in the ED are seen and treated. But using assessments as the basis for refusal of care to potential nonurgent patients raises legal, ethical, and safety issues. Managed care organizations should be cautious when applying such criteria to restrict access to EDs.In the past 30 years, the number of visits to emergency departments (EDs) has increased, inducing overcrowding in many countries [1]. ED overcrowding is related to multiple complex problems: overburdened inpatient facilities, inadequate ED space, insufficient staffing, and inaccessibility to primary care services [2-6]. ED overcrowding has resulted in a longer stay in the ED and worse outcomes for persons who truly require emergency care [2,7,8].Several review of the emergency medicine literat
%U http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-227X/11/19